🎧 Case Brief Lecture

MAGTANGGOL GABRIEL, COMPLAINANT, VS. ATTY. VIRGINIA C. ABELLA, DIVISION CLERK OF COURT OF THE 17TH DIVISION; OLIMPIA V. TRAMBULO, RECORDS OFFICER III, RECEIVING SECTION; FERDINA…

A.M. No. CA-99-9-P. April 30, 2003 April 30, 2003

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Magtanggol Gabriel versus Atty. Virginia Abella

The Case

This is an administrative complaint for grave misconduct filed by Magtanggol Gabriel, a corporate vice president and litigant before the Court of Appeals, against three employees of that court: Atty. Virginia Abella, the Division Clerk of Court of the Seventeenth Division; Olimpia Trambulo, Records Officer of the Receiving Section; and Ferdinand Heramis, Clerk of the Civil Cases Section. The complaint grows out of a premature entry of judgment and the loss of a motion for reconsideration inside the court's own records system. The case matters because it fixes the standard of conduct for judicial personnel — courtesy, diligence, and care in the custody of pleadings — and shows how the Supreme Court disciplines even the lowest employees of the judiciary when that standard is breached.

Procedural History

The complainant filed his affidavit-complaint before the Office of the Court Administrator. The complaint was referred to then Acting Presiding Justice Arturo Buena of the Court of Appeals for investigation, report, and recommendation, and he in turn directed Assistant Clerk of Court Elisa Pilar-Longalong to conduct the investigation. She submitted a report recommending dismissal as to Atty. Abella, reprimand as to Trambulo, and suspension as to Heramis, and Justice Buena adopted the report and transmitted it to the Court Administrator. The Court Administrator agreed and further recommended that Alberto Tariga, Jr., the verification clerk whose erroneous report triggered the premature entry of judgment, be included as a respondent. The Supreme Court then issued a resolution dismissing the charges against Atty. Abella and requiring Tariga to comment. The case is an original administrative matter decided by the Supreme Court itself.

Facts

Magtanggol Gabriel was vice president of Manila Metal Container Corporation, the plaintiff-appellant in a civil case pending before the Seventeenth Division of the Court of Appeals. On May 15, 1998, upon the motion of the intervenor Reynaldo Tolentino, the Division issued a resolution substituting the intervenor as plaintiff and granting the withdrawal of the appeal. On May 27, 1998, Gabriel filed a motion for reconsideration of that resolution, and on the same day the intervenor also filed his own motion for reconsideration, praying for an entry of judgment.

Acting on the intervenor's motion, Atty. Abella prepared and issued an entry of judgment even though Gabriel's motion for reconsideration was still pending. Gabriel went to the Receiving Section to ask for a certification that his counsel had filed the motion, but Trambulo refused to issue it and spoke to him in a loud and belligerent voice, saying she did not have custody of the records. Gabriel also complained that Heramis mishandled the motion: Heramis first denied receiving it, then admitted he had received it from the Receiving Section and recorded it in the Civil Cases Docket Book.

In her defense, Atty. Abella said she followed the internal rules of the Court of Appeals and the Rules of Civil Procedure, having waited for the reglementary period to lapse, verified with the Judicial Records Division that no motion for reconsideration had been filed, and secured the ponente's marginal note directing the entry of judgment; she received Gabriel's motion only on June 22, 1998. Trambulo denied arrogance and explained that she spoke loudly only to stress why she could not issue the certification. Heramis claimed he recorded the motion and placed it on the table of the rollo clerk, Augusto Alba, without asking for an acknowledgment of receipt. The investigation found that Atty. Abella had exercised due diligence, that Trambulo's conduct was unjustified, and that Heramis was negligent, since the index card showed the motion was entered only on June 5, 1998, not June 1 as he claimed, and he was last seen with the lost pleading.

Issues

  • Whether or not Atty. Virginia Abella is guilty of grave misconduct for issuing the entry of judgment while a motion for reconsideration was pending.
  • Whether or not Olimpia Trambulo is guilty of discourtesy for refusing the requested certification and speaking to the complainant in a loud voice.
  • Whether or not Alberto Tariga, Jr. is liable for the erroneous report that no motion for reconsideration had been filed.
  • Whether or not Ferdinand Heramis is guilty of negligence in the discharge of his official duties over the motion for reconsideration.

Applicable Provisions

The Court cites the Civil Service Law and Rules on discourtesy as a light offense. Rule Fourteen, Section Twenty-three of the Civil Service Law and Rules provides:

Under Rule XIV, Sec. 23 of the Civil Service Law and Rules, a first offense of discourtesy, which is a light penalty, in the course of one’s official duties shall be meted the penalty of reprimand.

This fixes the penalty of reprimand for Trambulo's first offense of discourtesy.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court dismissed the charge against Atty. Abella. The conduct required of court personnel must always be beyond reproach, but she had exercised due diligence: she waited for the reglementary period, verified the records, and acted on the ponente's marginal note. There was no grave misconduct on her part.

On the second issue, the Court found Trambulo guilty of discourtesy. Discourtesy and disrespect have no place in the judiciary. Even if she had a logical justification to refuse the certification, there was no reason for such high-strung conduct. As a public officer she is bound to observe courtesy, civility, and self-restraint in dealing with the public, even when confronted with rudeness. Applying the Civil Service rule, a first offense of discourtesy carries the penalty of reprimand.

On the third issue, the Court held Tariga liable for his erroneous report, which served as the basis for the premature entry of judgment; his participation in the irregularities was indispensable. He was admonished to be more circumspect in verifying pleadings and submitting reports to the Division Clerks.

On the fourth issue, the Court found Heramis negligent. Being in the Records Division, he was tasked to keep track of pleadings, yet he deliberately did not ask the rollo clerk to acknowledge receipt. His neglect derailed the administration of justice and eroded public faith in the judiciary. He was suspended for one month without pay.

Doctrine

First, the conduct of everyone in the judiciary, from the judge to the lowest personnel, must be beyond reproach, because the image of a court of justice is mirrored in their conduct. Second, discourtesy and disrespect have no place in the judiciary; a public officer must observe courtesy, civility, and self-restraint even when confronted with rudeness, and a first offense of discourtesy is penalized by reprimand under the Civil Service Law and Rules. Third, records personnel are duty-bound to faithfully keep track of pleadings, and failure to secure acknowledgment of receipt of a pleading constitutes negligence punishable by suspension. Fourth, a verification clerk who submits an erroneous report on which the Division Clerk relies is liable and may be admonished.

Disposition

The Court reprimanded Trambulo for discourteous conduct, admonished Tariga to be more circumspect, suspended Heramis for one month without pay for negligence, directed the records divisions to institute remedial measures, and sternly warned all respondents that a repetition would be dealt with more severely; the charge against Atty. Abella was dismissed.

Remember This

Memorize the line that the image of a court of justice is mirrored in the conduct of the men and women who work therein, from the judge to the lowest of its personnel. Examiners use this case in administrative ethics and judicial discipline questions on discourtesy, negligence of records personnel, and the standard of conduct required of judiciary employees.