TERESITA C. LAI, PETITIONER, V. HON. LEANDRO M. JOSE, SHERIFF JACOBO C. ABRIL, JOANN G. MINAS AND EVANGELINE CONGE, RESPONDENTS.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Lai versus Jose
The Case
This is Teresita C. Lai against Honorable Leandro M. Jose, Sheriff Jacobo C. Abril, Joann G. Minas, and Evangeline Conge. The petitioner, Teresita C. Lai, originally came to the Supreme Court on a petition for mandamus, seeking to compel the issuance of a certificate of redemption. But before the Court could resolve the merits, the parties settled their dispute in a separate administrative case before the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources, and that settlement covered this case as well. The petitioner then asked the Court to dismiss her own petition, and the private respondents interposed no objection. The case matters less for any novel doctrine than for what it teaches about mootness and the proper disposition of a petition that events have overtaken: when the relief prayed for has already been granted by the parties themselves, the Court will not insist on deciding a question that no longer exists.
Procedural History
The petitioner filed a petition for mandamus directly with the Supreme Court, praying that the private respondents be compelled to execute a certificate of redemption. While that petition was pending, the petitioner filed a manifestation and motion to dismiss, informing the Court that she and the private respondents had entered into a compromise agreement in a separate case before the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources, and that under that agreement the private respondents had already executed the certificate of redemption she was asking the Court to order. The private respondents, through counsel, filed a compliance and manifestation stating that they interposed no objection to the withdrawal or dismissal of the case, since it had been rendered moot and academic by the compromise agreement. The Supreme Court then resolved the motion.
Facts
Teresita C. Lai was the petitioner in a petition for mandamus pending before the Supreme Court. The relief she sought was the issuance of a certificate of redemption, which she prayed the Court to compel from the private respondents, Joann G. Minas and Evangeline Conge. The other named respondents were Honorable Leandro M. Jose and Sheriff Jacobo C. Abril.
While the petition was pending, a separate case involving the petitioner and private respondent Joann G. Minas was also pending before the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. In that separate case, the parties decided to enter into a compromise agreement in order to settle their differences amicably, and their settlement expressly included the present case.
Under the compromise agreement, the petitioner agreed to pay, and the private respondents agreed to receive, the sum of 250,000 pesos as a complete settlement of the petitioner's obligations to them. As a consequence, the private respondents already executed the certificate of redemption, which was precisely what the petitioner was praying for in her petition for mandamus. On these developments, the petitioner moved to dismiss or withdraw her petition on the ground that the issues had been rendered moot and academic, and the private respondents interposed no objection.
Issues
- Whether or not the petition for mandamus should be dismissed or withdrawn on the ground that the issues therein had been rendered moot and academic by the execution of a compromise agreement between the parties.
- Whether or not the petitioner may obtain the dismissal of the very petition she herself filed, where the private respondents interpose no objection thereto.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote or construe any statutory or constitutional provision. It rests entirely on the procedural effect of a compromise agreement and the supervening mootness of the relief prayed for. The governing text is the petitioner's own motion, which states the ground for dismissal:
That in view of the said developments, it is humbly submitted that the issues in this case have been rendered moot and academic, thus no longer requiring the resolution by this Honorable Court.
This allegation is the operative basis for the dismissal, because it shows that no live controversy remained for the Court to resolve.
The private respondents' manifestation supplies the second element, namely, their consent to the dismissal:
Private respondents JOANN G. MINAS and EVANGELINE CONGE, through their undersigned counsel, unto this Honorable Court respectfully manifest that they interpose no objection to the withdrawal/dismissal of the instant case in view of the fact that the same has been rendered moot and academic due to the execution of the Compromise Agreement among the parties.
With the ground for dismissal alleged by the petitioner and unopposed by the private respondents, nothing remained to litigate.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petition had indeed been rendered moot and academic. The very relief sought in the petition for mandamus was the certificate of redemption, and that certificate had already been executed by the private respondents pursuant to the compromise agreement. There was therefore no longer any live controversy for the Court to resolve, and no judicial order could give the petitioner anything she did not already have.
On the second issue, the Court held that the petitioner's prayer for the dismissal of her own petition was justified. The Court reasoned that the petitioner sought the dismissal of the very petition she filed, and that the dismissal was not objected to by the private respondents. On that basis, the Court granted the motion.
Doctrine
A petition is rendered moot and academic when the relief prayed for has already been obtained, or when the parties have by their own agreement settled the matter, so that no live controversy remains for the Court to decide. A court will not resolve a question that no longer has any practical effect on the parties.
A petitioner may move for the dismissal or withdrawal of his or her own petition, and where the adverse party interposes no objection, the prayer for dismissal is justified and should be granted. The consent of the private respondents, coupled with the supervening event that satisfied the relief sought, removes any obstacle to dismissal.
A compromise agreement that expressly covers a pending case operates to settle that case, and the performance of the parties' obligations under it, here the execution of the certificate of redemption, extinguishes the controversy. A Bar candidate should state the rule this way: supervening mootness, established by the satisfaction of the relief prayed for and confirmed by the adverse party's lack of objection, warrants the dismissal of the petition.
Disposition
The Court granted the petitioner's manifestation and motion to dismiss, dismissed the petition, and deemed the case closed and terminated.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: when the relief prayed for has already been obtained through a compromise agreement and the adverse party interposes no objection, the petition is moot and academic and must be dismissed. Examiners use this case for the procedural point that a petitioner may secure the dismissal of his or her own petition, and for the rule that courts will not decide a controversy that events have already settled.