SPOUSES REMEGIO P. BUIZON AND FLOR BUIZON, IN THEIR OWN BEHALF AND IN BEHALF OF THE HEIRS OF CATALINO TUAZON-VICTOR, RUPERTO TUAZON, JULIAN TUAZON, EMERITO TUAZON, APOLONIA TUAZ…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Buizon versus Dugenio
The Case
This is a case about a registered parcel of land in Pasig City and the people who built on it without the owner's consent. The plaintiffs, the Buizon spouses and the heirs of the Tuazon family, sued the defendants, the Dugenio spouses, the Mundala spouses, and Themestocles Sulat, to recover possession of a nine hundred twenty square meter lot covered by a Torrens certificate of title. The action is one for recovery of possession, an accion publiciana, and the defendants answered that they had occupied the land as owners since 1978 and had therefore acquired it by prescription. The case matters because it settles, in plain terms, that no length of occupation can defeat a Torrens title, and that the registered owner is entitled to possession as one of the attributes of ownership.
Procedural History
The plaintiffs filed their complaint for recovery of possession before the Regional Trial Court of Pasig City. After pre-trial and trial on the merits, the trial court, through Judge Maria Cheryl Laqui-Ceguera, rendered judgment in favor of the plaintiffs. It ordered the defendants and all persons claiming rights under them to remove the structures on the land and to deliver possession of the property to the plaintiffs, to pay fifty thousand pesos as attorney's fees, and to pay the costs of suit. The defendants appealed to the Court of Appeals, assigning as errors the trial court's reliance on the Torrens certificate as proof of ownership, its failure to find that the land they occupied was separate and distinct from the titled land, its failure to consider their occupation as owners since 1978, and its award of attorney's fees and costs. The Court of Appeals found the appeal devoid of merit, denied and dismissed it, and affirmed the judgment of the trial court in full.
Facts
The plaintiffs claimed to be the absolute and lawful co-owners of a nine hundred twenty square meter parcel of land at Interior F. Manalo Street, Barangay Santa Cruz, Pasig City, covered by Original Certificate of Title Number 5610. The property had a market value of five hundred eighty eight thousand eight hundred pesos based on a tax declaration issued by the City Assessor of Pasig City.
The defendants built structures on the property without the knowledge and consent of the plaintiffs, and thereafter the plaintiffs were prevented from entering the land. The matter was brought to barangay conciliation, where the defendants executed a document acknowledging the ownership of the plaintiffs over the property and promising to vacate it on or before the thirty first of January 2005. On that date, however, the defendants refused to vacate.
The plaintiffs then filed their complaint for recovery of possession on the thirtieth of October 2007. In their answer, the defendants countered that they had possessed the property in the concept of an owner since 1978 and had introduced improvements on it. They insisted that the plaintiffs were referring to a different property, that the complaint stated no cause of action, and they prayed for its dismissal. At trial, the plaintiffs presented the testimony of Flor Buizon, one of the co-owners, who relied on the document the defendants had signed acknowledging their ownership. The defendants, for their part, denied that they had signed any such document. The trial court also granted a motion for verification survey before pre-trial. The trial court found for the plaintiffs, and the defendants appealed.
Issues
- Whether or not a Torrens certificate of title in the name of the plaintiffs is evidence that the subject property is owned by them.
- Whether or not the property occupied by the defendants is separate and distinct from the property covered by the certificate of title claimed by the plaintiffs.
- Whether or not the defendants, having occupied the property in the concept of an owner since 1978, acquired ownership of it by prescription.
- Whether or not the plaintiffs are entitled to attorney's fees and costs of suit.
Applicable Provisions
Article 1126 of the Civil Code provides:
Prescription of ownership of lands registered under the Land Registration Act shall be governed by special laws.
This provision directs the Court to the special law on registered lands, and it is the reason the defendants' claim of acquisitive prescription cannot prosper against a titled property.
Act Number 496, the Land Registration Act, provides:
No land title to a registered land in derogation of that of the registered owner thereof shall be acquired by adverse possession.
This is the special law that governs, and it squarely bars the defendants from acquiring the registered land by long occupation.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that a Torrens certificate of title is the best evidence of ownership of registered land. It serves as evidence of an indefeasible title in favor of the persons whose names appear on it, and it is conclusive evidence with respect to the ownership of the land described therein. The titleholder is therefore entitled to all the attributes of ownership, including possession. The plaintiffs' title gave rise to the reasonable presumption that the defendants had no right over the land and that their stay was merely tolerated.
On the second issue, the Court found no merit in the claim that the defendants occupied a different property. The trial court had granted a verification survey precisely to settle that question, and the defendants failed to establish by preponderance of evidence that the land they occupied was separate and distinct from the titled land.
On the third issue, the Court held that lands covered by a land title cannot be acquired by prescription or adverse possession. The defendants' claim of acquisitive prescription was without basis. The trial court had also observed that the defendants admitted knowing the property was owned by the government, that they never caused its registration, and that they never had it declared for taxation in their names, so they could not be considered possessors in the concept of an owner. As against the Torrens title, their purported prior possession could not confer a better right, and no possession by any person of any portion of the land could defeat the title of the registered owners.
On the fourth issue, the Court upheld the award of attorney's fees and costs, since the defendants entered and occupied the plaintiffs' land without authority or right, and having no title or document to overcome the plaintiffs' ownership, they were intruders whose occupation was merely tolerated by the owners.
Doctrine
A Torrens certificate of title is the best evidence of ownership of registered land, is conclusive as to the ownership of the land described in it, and entitles the registered owner to all the attributes of ownership, including possession. No possession by any person of any portion of registered land can defeat the title of the registered owner.
Lands covered by a Torrens title cannot be acquired by prescription or adverse possession. This flows from Article 1126 of the Civil Code, which sends prescription of ownership of registered lands to the special laws, and from Act Number 496, which forbids the acquisition of a registered land title by adverse possession in derogation of the registered owner.
In an accion publiciana, the plaintiff seeks to recover possession only, not ownership, but when the parties raise the issue of ownership, the court may pass upon it to determine who between them has the better right to possess. A person who occupies registered land without title or authority is an intruder whose occupation is merely tolerated, and such occupation cannot affect the possession of the owner.
Disposition
The Court of Appeals denied and dismissed the appeal and affirmed the judgment of the trial court, so the plaintiffs won possession of the land, the removal of the structures, fifty thousand pesos in attorney's fees, and the costs of suit.
Remember This
Memorize this line: a Torrens title is the best evidence of ownership, and registered land cannot be acquired by prescription or adverse possession. Examiners use this case to test the accion publiciana, the conclusiveness of a Torrens title, and the rule that occupation of registered land without authority is merely tolerated and never ripens into ownership.