🎧 Case Brief Lecture

ROSITA ANDAMO VDA. DE GILLEGO, COMPLAINANT, VS. ATTY. HENRY AMADO ROXAS, CLERK OF COURT, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT BRANCH 55, SORSOGON, SORSOGON; AND JESUS GARLAN, SHERIFF IV, REGION…

A.M. No. P-91-611. August 05, 1994 August 5, 1994

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Gillego versus Roxas

The Case

This is an administrative complaint filed by Rosita Andamo Gillego against two court personnel of the Regional Trial Court of Sorsogon: Henry Amado Roxas, the Clerk of Court, and Jesus Garlan, a Deputy Sheriff. The complainant charges both with dereliction of duty for their failure to enforce a writ of execution in an ejectment case she had won. The case matters because it fixes the standard of conduct for sheriffs and clerks of court in executing final judgments: execution is not discretionary, and the ministerial duties of court personnel carry administrative consequences when neglected.

Procedural History

The complainant filed a sworn complaint before the Supreme Court. The Court required the two respondents to file their comments, which they did. The Court then referred the matter to the Executive Judge of the Regional Trial Court of Sorsogon for investigation, report, and recommendation. The Investigating Judge held hearings, but these were repeatedly postponed at the instance of the parties. When the parties failed to present evidence on the scheduled date, the Investigating Judge issued a report finding the Deputy Sheriff guilty of dereliction of duty and recommending dismissal of the charge against the Clerk of Court. The case then returned to the Supreme Court, which resolved it as an administrative matter.

Facts

In an ejectment case before the Municipal Trial Court of Bulan, Sorsogon, the complainant obtained a Special Order of Demolition directing the Deputy Sheriff to remove the portion of the defendants' residential house that had been illegally constructed on her lot. On 15 April 1991, the complainant paid the Clerk of Court 1,500 pesos as legal fees to cover the expenses of implementing the demolition. Despite this payment and the hiring of laborers, the Deputy Sheriff failed to appear on the date set for the demolition.

The Deputy Sheriff claimed that he had served an alias writ of demolition on the defendants' daughter, the actual occupant, and later on the defendant himself, advising them to vacate voluntarily. He said he was about to implement the demolition but the Clerk of Court was confined in the hospital, and he blamed the delay on the fact that the amount had been deposited with the Regional Trial Court Clerk of Court rather than the Municipal Trial Court Clerk of Court. The Clerk of Court, for his part, claimed he had immediately notified the Deputy Sheriff and constantly reminded him of the matter.

The record showed that the Clerk of Court received the 1,500 pesos on 15 April 1991 but transmitted it to the Deputy Sheriff only on 8 June 1992, more than a year later. Even after receiving the amount, the Deputy Sheriff still did not implement the writ, and he never filed a return. The failure to execute persisted despite a Special Order naming him, a letter from the Deputy Court Administrator directing him to comply without further delay, and an alias writ of execution issued on 30 July 1991.

Issues

  • Whether or not Deputy Sheriff Jesus Garlan is guilty of dereliction of duty for failing to implement the writ of execution.
  • Whether or not Clerk of Court Henry Amado Roxas is guilty of neglect of duty for his delay in remitting the estimated expenses of demolition to the Deputy Sheriff.

Applicable Provisions

Rule 141, Section 9 of the Rules of Court, as cited in the decision, provides:

Under Rule 141, Section 9 of the Rules of Court, Deputy Sheriff Garlan was obliged to secure the approval of the issuing court of the estimated expenses and fees for implementation of the Writ of Execution.

This provision bears on the case because it defines the sheriff's duty regarding the expenses of execution, which the Deputy Sheriff failed to observe.

Rule 39, Section 11 of the Rules of Court, as cited in the decision, provides:

Under Rule 39, Section 11 of the Rules of Court, Deputy Sheriff Garlan was obliged to make a return of the Writ of Execution at any time not less than ten (10) days and not more than sixty (60) days from receipt thereof.

This provision bears on the case because the Deputy Sheriff never filed a return within the mandatory period, compounding his failure to execute.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court agreed with the Investigating Judge that the Deputy Sheriff was guilty of dereliction of duty. His failure to implement the writ persisted despite a series of orders, including a Special Order naming him, a directive from the Deputy Court Administrator to comply without further delay, and an alias writ of execution. The Court rejected his excuse that the Clerk of Court's delay in remitting the amount justified his own delay. The Court held that the requirements of execution and return are mandatory, and that the sheriff is left with no discretion on whether or not to execute and to make a return within the period fixed by the Rules. The Court also rejected his claim that he had tried to persuade the occupants to vacate voluntarily, holding that upon finality of the judgment and issuance of the writ, the time for persuasion was over and his duty was to carry out the writ.

On the second issue, the Court disagreed with the Investigating Judge's recommendation to dismiss the charge against the Clerk of Court. The Court held that the Clerk of Court was remiss in his own duty promptly to remit the sum representing the estimated expenses of demolition to the Deputy Sheriff. He offered no sensible reason for holding on to the deposit for an inordinately long period, and by the time he remitted the amount, the alias writ had itself become stale.

Doctrine

A sheriff's duty to execute a writ and to make a return within the period fixed by the Rules of Court is mandatory and ministerial; the sheriff has no discretion on whether or not to execute and to make a return. The time for persuasion ends upon the finality of the judgment and the issuance of the writ of execution. A clerk of court who holds on to funds deposited for the expenses of execution without promptly remitting them to the sheriff is guilty of neglect of duty. Court personnel who fail in these ministerial duties are administratively liable.

Disposition

The Court found Clerk of Court Henry Amado Roxas guilty of neglect of duty and reprimanded him with a warning, and found Deputy Sheriff Jesus Garlan guilty of dereliction of duty and suspended him for six months with a warning.

Remember This

Execution is mandatory and ministerial; the sheriff has no discretion to delay it, and the clerk of court must promptly remit execution funds. Examiners use this case to test the administrative liability of court personnel for neglect of the ministerial duties attached to execution.