🎧 Case Brief Lecture

SPOUSES ERNESTO GALICIA AND JULIA M. PADAYOGYOG-GALICIA, PETITIONERS, VS. MARCELINA CONSTANTINO VDA. DE LOZANO, REPRESENTED BY YOLANDA RAMOS, AND THE HEIRS OF MARCELINA CONSTANT…

June 10, 1992

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Galicia versus Lozano

The Case

This is Galicia versus Lozano, a petition for review brought by the spouses Ernesto Galicia and Julia Padayogyog-Galicia against Marcelina Constantino, widow of the late Blas Lozano, represented by Yolanda Ramos. The action began as a complaint for repossession and damages over a portion of a farmholding awarded to Blas Lozano under Presidential Decree Number 27, the land reform law that emancipated the tiller from the bondage of the soil. The case matters because it settles, in plain terms, that a farmer-beneficiary cannot mortgage or sell his awarded land to anyone except the government or his heirs by hereditary succession, and that any such mortgage or sale is void from the very beginning.

Procedural History

The complaint for repossession and damages was filed with the Provincial Adjudicator for Cauayan, Isabela, the Honorable Pepito M. Planta. In his decision of March 8, 2000, the Provincial Adjudicator dismissed the complaint for lack of merit, maintained the Galicia spouses in peaceful possession and cultivation pending a land transfer action, and directed the Provincial Agrarian Reform Officer to initiate proceedings to determine the re-allocatee of the land and to seek cancellation of the emancipation patent issued to the Lozano family.

Marcelina Constantino appealed to the Department of Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board, which reversed and set aside the Provincial Adjudicator's decision in its Decision of June 24, 2005. The Board ordered the Galicia spouses to surrender possession and cultivation to Marcelina Constantino, and directed her to pay them the amounts she had borrowed and the consideration of the deed of sale, with legal interest. The Board denied the spouses' motion for reconsideration in its Resolution of October 3, 2005.

The Galicia spouses then came to the Supreme Court by petition for review, assigning errors of fact and law against the Board's decision.

Facts

Blas Lozano was a farmer-beneficiary of the Anita Diego Estate in Barangay Estrella, San Mateo, Isabela. He was awarded an area of about 1.1715 hectares, for which he was issued a certificate of land transfer, and he held the land as a beneficiary under Presidential Decree Number 27.

Sometime in 1992, Blas Lozano and his wife Marcelina mortgaged the land to the Galicia spouses for 50,000 pesos, with the agreement that the latter would cultivate it. A second loan of 20,000 pesos followed, to cover Blas Lozano's medical expenses. Blas Lozano died on April 23, 1995. After his death, Marcelina executed a deed of absolute sale conveying the land to the Galicia spouses for 96,795 pesos.

Marcelina later claimed she never sold the land. She continued paying the land amortizations with the Land Bank of the Philippines and tried to redeem the property, but the Galicia spouses refused, insisting they were now the owners. She even offered to pay 109,000 pesos to avoid litigation, but they refused to accept payment and to vacate. The matter reached the Legal Division of the Department of Agrarian Reform Provincial Office in Isabela, and the barangay captain of Estrella could not settle it because the Galicia spouses refused to appear at the scheduled conferences.

Issues

  • Whether or not the Department of Agrarian Reform Adjudication Board erred in ordering the petitioners to surrender the peaceful possession and cultivation of the land to Marcelina Constantino.
  • Whether or not the Board erred in finding that Marcelina Constantino had no intention to transfer ownership of the land and that she had paid its amortizations.
  • Whether or not the Board erred in entertaining the personality of Yolanda Ramos as representative of Marcelina Constantino.

Applicable Provisions

Presidential Decree Number 27, the land reform decree under which Blas Lozano was awarded his landholding, provides:

Title to land acquired pursuant to this Decree or the Land Reform Program of the Government shall not be transferable except to the grantee's heirs by hereditary succession or except back to the Government by other legal means.

This is the provision the Court applies: it forbids any transfer of the awarded land other than to the grantee's heirs or back to the government, which makes the mortgage and sale to the Galicia spouses void.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the Board did not err. It was undisputed that Blas Lozano was a farmer-beneficiary under Presidential Decree Number 27 of an 11,715-square meter parcel covered by a certificate of land transfer. As a beneficiary, he was emancipated from the bondage of the soil and gained the rights to possess, cultivate, and enjoy the landholding for himself, and those rights were granted to him and to no other. To insure his continued possession and enjoyment, he could not make any valid form of transfer except to the government or, by hereditary succession, to his successors. The Court quoted the decree:

Title to land acquired pursuant to this Decree or the Land Reform Program of the Government shall not be transferable except to the grantee's heirs by hereditary succession or except back to the Government by other legal means.

The Court stressed that the law is clear and leaves no room for interpretation. Although the Lozano spouses had mortgaged a 6,000-square meter portion for 70,000 pesos and later sold it for 96,795 pesos, both transactions violated the express mandate of the decree and were void from the beginning. Because they were void, they must be given no effect at all, and the parties must be restored to the status quo prevailing before their execution. Hence the Board correctly ordered the petitioners to surrender possession and cultivation, and Marcelina Constantino to return the borrowed amounts and the 96,795-peso consideration, with legal interest.

On the second issue, the Court rejected the claim of abandonment. Abandonment requires the concurrence of two elements: the intent to abandon a right or claim, and the external act by which that intention is expressed and carried into effect. There must be an actual, not merely projected, relinquishment of the right. Here, despite executing the deed of sale, Marcelina continued to claim and assert dominion over the land. She kept paying the amortizations with the Land Bank of the Philippines, as shown by a certification issued in July 1999, and she offered to redeem the land. These acts negated any intention to transfer ownership, and a person would not waste money, effort, and time prosecuting an unworthy action.

Having so ruled, the Court found it no longer necessary to address the third assigned error on the personality of Yolanda Ramos.

Doctrine

A farmer-beneficiary under Presidential Decree Number 27 is emancipated from the bondage of the soil and acquires the rights to possess, cultivate, and enjoy the landholding for himself alone. Title to land acquired under the decree or the Land Reform Program is not transferable except to the grantee's heirs by hereditary succession or back to the government by other legal means. Any mortgage, sale, or other conveyance made in violation of this prohibition is void from the beginning and produces no effect; the parties must be restored to the status quo before the void transaction. Agrarian laws are interpreted liberally in favor of the grantees, to achieve a dignified existence for the small farmers. Finally, abandonment requires both the intent to abandon and an external act carrying that intent into effect, and the relinquishment must be actual, not merely projected; continued payment of amortizations and efforts to redeem negate any intent to abandon.

Disposition

The Supreme Court denied due course to and dismissed the petition, without costs, thereby affirming the Board's decision that the Galicia spouses must surrender the land to Marcelina Constantino, who in turn must return the loan amounts and the 96,795-peso consideration with legal interest.

Remember This

Memorize the line that title under Presidential Decree Number 27 is not transferable except to the grantee's heirs by hereditary succession or back to the government, so any mortgage or sale to a private person is void from the beginning. Examiners use this case to test the void-from-the-beginning character of prohibited conveyances of awarded land and the two-element test for abandonment of a farmholding.