🎧 Case Brief Lecture

OSCAR ABETO, COMPLAINANT, VS. MANUEL GARCESA, STENOGRA­PHIC REPORTER, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 45, BACOLOD CITY, RESPONDENT.

A.M. No. P-88-269. December 29, 1995 December 29, 1995

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Abeto versus Garcesa

The Case

This is an administrative case in which Oscar Abeto charges Manuel Garcesa, a stenographic reporter of Branch 45 of the Regional Trial Court of Bacolod City, with having misrepresented himself as a full-fledged lawyer and with having acted as one of the authorized representatives of the complainant and his co-complainants in labor cases pending before the National Labor Relations Commission in Bacolod City, despite being a court employee. The case matters because it draws the line between two distinct offenses that a judiciary employee might commit: the unauthorized practice of law, on the one hand, and moonlighting or engaging in private activity without permission, on the other. The Court acquits the respondent of the first but holds him liable for the second, and in doing so fixes the standard that governs every official and employee of the Judiciary.

Procedural History

The verified complaint, dated 19 October 1988, was received by the Office of the Court Administrator on 18 November 1988. The then Deputy Court Administrator, Meynardo Tiro, referred the complaint to the respondent through the Presiding Judge of Branch 45 of the Regional Trial Court of Bacolod City and required him to comment. The respondent filed his Comment or Explanation. On 28 August 1989, then Deputy Court Administrator Juanito Bernad submitted a memorandum recommending that the complaint for misrepresentation be dismissed, but that the respondent be advised to heed the Civil Service Rules and the memorandum circular of this Court prohibiting government employees from engaging in any private business, vocation, or profession without permission. In July 1995 the respondent filed a Letter-Petition asking for early resolution and inviting attention to the complainant's affidavit of desistance. By resolution of 18 September 1995, the Supreme Court directed the Office of the Court Administrator to reevaluate the case and submit a report. On 13 October 1995, Deputy Court Administrator Zenaida Elepaño submitted a memorandum, duly approved by the Court Administrator, finding the respondent liable and recommending the penalty of reprimand. The case was thus resolved by the Supreme Court as an administrative matter, on the basis of that memorandum and recommendation.

Facts

Oscar Abeto and other workers of BISCOM Central sought to file and prosecute labor cases before Regional Arbitration Branch VI of the National Labor Relations Commission in Bacolod City. No lawyer would then take up their cause, so they sought the assistance of Arturo Ronquillo, Vice President of the Workers Amalgamated Union of the Philippines. When the respondent first met the complainant in December 1986, he frankly told him that he was only a court employee and that he was merely assisting Arturo Ronquillo.

In an Ex-Parte Formal Manifestation dated 11 August 1988, the respondent and Arturo Ronquillo signed as authorized representatives of the complainants in several labor cases. In his Comment or Explanation, the respondent admitted having extended casual assistance to Arturo Ronquillo in the filing and prosecution of those cases, but denied having misrepresented himself as a lawyer. He explained that the complaint arose out of ill feeling and was designed to malign his name and reputation, and manifested that if his motives in helping the poor and downtrodden workers were considered contrary to the governing circulars, he would readily submit to the discretion of the Supreme Court.

Later, the complainant executed an affidavit of desistance and wrote the Court requesting that the case be dismissed. The respondent himself asked for early resolution, calling the case baseless and an offshoot of a petty misunderstanding.

Issues

  • Whether or not the respondent is liable for unauthorized practice of law or for misrepresenting himself as a full-fledged lawyer.
  • Whether or not the respondent is liable for violating Section 12, Rule XVIII of the Revised Civil Service Rules and Administrative Circular No. 5 dated 4 October 1988, by engaging in a limited law practice without permission from the Court.
  • Whether or not the complainant's affidavit of desistance and the respondent's good intentions absolve him from administrative liability.

Applicable Provisions

Section 12, Rule XVIII of the Revised Civil Service Rules provides:

Section 12. No officer or employee shall engage directly in any private business, vocation, or profession or be connected with any commercial, credit, agricultural or industrial undertaking without a written permission from the head of Department: Provided, That this prohibition will be absolute in the case of those officers and employees whose duties and responsibilities require that their entire time be at the disposal of the Government: Provided, further, That if an employee is granted permission to engage in outside activities, the time so devoted outside of office hours should be fixed by the chief of the agency to the end that it will not impair in any way the efficiency of the officer or employee: And provided, finally, That no permission is necessary in the case of investments, made by an officer or employee, which do not involve any real or apparent conflict between his private interests and public duties, or in any way influence him in the discharge of his duties, and he shall not take part in the management of the enterprise or become an officer or member of the board of directors.

This is the rule the respondent was found to have violated by engaging in a limited law practice without written permission.

Administrative Circular No. 5 dated 4 October 1988 states the Court's view:

The entire time of Judiciary officials and employees must be devoted to government service to insure efficient and speedy administration of justice considering the express prohibition in the Rules of Court and the nature of their work which requires them to serve with the highest degree of efficiency and responsibility, in order to maintain public confidence in the Judiciary.

This circular supplies the standard for judiciary personnel and explains why the executive rule on outside activities does not govern them.

Section 6, Rule IV of the Revised Rules of Procedure of the National Labor Relations Commission, in force at the time, provides:

A non-lawyer may appear before the Commission or any Labor Arbiter if he represents himself as a party to the case, represents an organization or its members, or is a duly accredited member of a free legal aid staff of the Department of Labor and Employment or of any other legal aid office accredited by the Department of Justice or the Integrated Bar of the Philippines.

This provision is why the respondent's appearance as a representative, and not as a lawyer, did not amount to unauthorized practice of law.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the respondent could not be liable for unauthorized practice of law, since there was no convincing evidence that he misrepresented himself as a lawyer. His appearance was in his capacity as one of the representatives of the complainants in the labor cases and not as a lawyer, and under the NLRC rule then in force a non-lawyer may appear before the Commission or any Labor Arbiter when he represents an organization or its members.

On the second issue, the Court held him liable. The respondent and Arturo Ronquillo had signed as authorized representatives in the labor cases, and he admitted having extended casual assistance in their filing and prosecution. His justification, that he wished to help the poor and downtrodden workers, did not absolve him from administrative liability for violating Section 12, Rule XVIII of the Revised Civil Service Rules and the rulings of the Court in the Valdez and Rabanal cases, which were incorporated in Administrative Circular No. 5. The Court also held that Memorandum Circular No. 17 of the Executive Department, which lodges the authority to grant permission to engage in outside activities in the head of the ministry or agency, does not apply to officials and employees of the courts, because of the express prohibition in the Rules of Court and the nature of judicial work. The Court characterized the prohibited conduct as moonlighting, which amounts to malfeasance in office.

On the third issue, the Court did not treat the affidavit of desistance or the respondent's good intentions as a defense. It agreed with the recommendation of Deputy Court Administrator Elepaño that the respondent merited at the very least a reprimand for engaging in a limited law practice, and it imposed that penalty for malfeasance in office.

Doctrine

First, a non-lawyer does not commit unauthorized practice of law when he appears before the National Labor Relations Commission as a representative of a party or of an organization, rather than as a lawyer; misrepresentation must be shown by convincing evidence.

Second, every official and employee of the Judiciary is absolutely prohibited from engaging, directly or indirectly, in any private business, vocation, or profession without written permission from the Court, because the entire time of judiciary personnel must be devoted to government service. This is the rule of Section 12, Rule XVIII of the Revised Civil Service Rules as applied through Administrative Circular No. 5.

Third, Memorandum Circular No. 17 of the Executive Department does not apply to officials and employees of the courts; the authority to permit outside activity in the Judiciary rests with the Supreme Court, not with the head of an executive ministry or agency.

Fourth, such unauthorized outside activity is moonlighting, and moonlighting amounts to malfeasance in office. Good intentions and the complainant's desistance do not erase the administrative offense.

Disposition

The Court reprimanded the respondent, Manuel Garcesa, for malfeasance in office consisting in the violation of Section 12, Rule XVIII of the Revised Civil Service Rules and of the rulings embodied in Administrative Circular No. 5, and warned him that the commission of the same or similar acts in the future would be dealt with more severely.

Remember This

The one line to memorize is that the entire time of judiciary officials and employees must be devoted to government service, so any private vocation without the Court's written permission is moonlighting and malfeasance in office. Examiners use this case to test the distinction between unauthorized practice of law, which requires proof of misrepresentation, and the absolute prohibition on outside employment for court personnel, which does not depend on good intentions or on the complainant's desistance.