🎧 Case Brief Lecture

CIRILO I. MERCADO, ARSENIO L. CARPIO, PEDRO V. SORIANO AND FLORDELIZA C. ALEJO, COMPLAINANTS, VS. JUDGE HECTOR F. DYSANGCO, IN HIS CAPACITY AS ACTING JUDGE OF 2ND MUNICIPAL CIRC…

A.M. No. MTJ-00-1301. July 30, 2002 July 30, 2002

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Mercado versus Dysangco

The Case

This is an administrative case filed with the Supreme Court against Judge Hector F. Dysangco, then Acting Presiding Judge of the Second Municipal Circuit Trial Court of Natividad-Llanera, Nueva Ecija, and against Teresita S. Esteban, Clerk of Court of the same court. The complainants — Cirilo I. Mercado, Arsenio L. Carpio, Pedro V. Soriano, and Flordeliza C. Alejo — charged both respondents with grave misconduct arising from an order of inclusion issued just before the barangay elections of May 1997. The case matters because it fixes the standard for petitions for inclusion of voters under the Omnibus Election Code, and because it reminds every judge that a personal interview is not a hearing, and that the cold neutrality of an impartial judge is the litigant's first right.

Procedural History

The complainants filed a sworn complaint dated May 29, 1997. The respondents filed separate comments. In a memorandum dated March 17, 1999, the Office of the Court Administrator found the comments unsatisfactory, and the Supreme Court referred the case to the Executive Judge of the Regional Trial Court of Cabanatuan City for investigation, report, and recommendation. Executive Judge Johnson L. Ballutay submitted his findings on January 3, 2000, recommending a fine of 5,000 pesos against the judge and reprimand for the clerk of court. The Court Administrator, in a memorandum dated October 12, 2000, likewise recommended a 5,000-peso fine for the judge and dismissal of the complaint against the clerk of court. On February 11, 2002, the Supreme Court dismissed the complaint against Clerk of Court Teresita S. Esteban. The case against the judge remained, and the Court decided it in this resolution.

Facts

Before the barangay elections of May 12, 1997, forty-eight persons filed with the municipal circuit trial court separate petitions for inclusion in the voters' list of Barangay Kabulihan, General Natividad, Nueva Ecija. Nine of them supported complainant Cirilo Mercado; thirty-nine supported his opponent, Alejandro Gonzales, both candidates for Barangay Chairman. The complainants opposed the petitions of the thirty-nine.

Hearings were set for April 17, April 28, May 6, May 8, and May 9, 1997. The first three were cancelled for absence of either the judge or counsel. On May 8, only the nine Mercado supporters presented evidence. The thirty-nine Gonzales supporters asked for postponement to May 9, but on that day neither they nor their counsel appeared, and the judge dismissed their petitions in open court. On Saturday, May 10, the judge assured the complainants he had issued no order of inclusion. Yet on election day, thirty-four of the thirty-nine were voting on the strength of an order signed by the judge and attested by the clerk of court.

The judge claimed his order rested on personal interviews with the petitioners on April 25, 1997. The investigation showed no notice of hearing was sent to the parties or their counsel; the stenographer testified the proceeding was a mere interview, with no trial and no lawyers; the clerk of court confirmed there was no hearing, only an interview. The petitions had been filed before April 17, but the order came only on May 9, two days before the election.

Issues

  • Whether or not respondent judge is guilty of gross ignorance of the law for issuing the order of inclusion without a hearing and beyond the ten-day period fixed by the Omnibus Election Code.
  • Whether or not respondent judge is guilty of grave misconduct constituting a violation of the Code of Judicial Conduct for exhibiting partiality and issuing the order surreptitiously.
  • Whether or not the penalty recommended by the investigating judge and the Court Administrator is commensurate to the offenses committed.

Applicable Provisions

Section 143 of Batas Pambansa Blg. 881, the Omnibus Election Code, provides:

SEC. 143. Common rules governing judicial proceedings in the matter of inclusion, exclusion, and correction of names of voters. - (a) Outside of regular office hours, no petition for inclusion, exclusion, or correction of names of voters shall be received. (b) Notices to the members of the board of election inspectors and to challenged voters shall state the place, day and hour in which such petition shall be heard, and such notice may be made by sending a copy thereof by registered mail or by personal delivery or by leaving it in the possession of a person of sufficient discretion in the residence of the said person or, in the event that the foregoing procedure is not practicable, by posting a copy in a conspicuous place in the city hall or municipal building and in two other conspicuous places within the city or municipality, at least ten days prior to the day set for the hearing. In the interest of justice and to afford the challenged voter every opportunity to contest the petition for exclusion, the court concerned may, when the challenged voter fails to appear in the first day set for the hearing, order that notice be effected in such manner and within such period of time as it may decide, which time shall in no case be more than ten days from the day the respondent is first found in default. (c) Each petition shall refer to only one precinct. (d) No costs shall be assessed in these proceedings. However, if the court should be satisfied that the application has been filed for the sole purpose of molesting the adverse party and causing him to incur expenses, it may condemn the culpable party to pay the costs and incidental expenses. (e) Any candidate who may be affected by the proceedings may intervene and present his evidence. (f) The decision shall be based on the evidence presented. If the question is whether or not the voter is real or fictitious, his non-appearance on the day set for hearing shall be prima facie evidence that the registered voter is fictitious. In no case shall a decision be rendered upon a stipulation of facts. (g)These applications shall be heard and decided without delay. The decision shall be rendered within six hours after the hearing and within ten days from the date of its filing in court. Cases appealed to the regional trial court shall be decided within ten days from receipt of the appeal in the office of the clerk of court. In any case, the court shall decide these petitions not later than the day before the election and the decision rendered thereon shall be immediately final and executory, notwithstanding the provision of Section 138 on the finality of decisions.

This provision supplies the three duties the respondent judge failed to perform: to hear the petition, to decide it on the evidence presented, and to decide it within ten days from filing.

Canon 2, Rule 2.01 of the Code of Judicial Conduct provides:

a judge should so behave at all times as to promote public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary.

This is the standard against which the judge's partiality and surreptitious issuance of the order are measured.

Section 11 of Rule 140 of the Revised Rules of Court provides:

SEC. 11. Sanctions. – A. If the respondent is guilty of a serious charge, any of the following sanctions may be imposed: Dismissal from the service, forfeiture of all or part of the benefits as the Court may determine, and disqualification from reinstatement or appointment to any public office, including government-owned or controlled corporations. Provided, however, that the forfeiture of benefits shall in no case include accrued leave credits; Suspension from office without salary and other benefits for more than three (3) but not exceeding six (6) months; or A fine of more than P20,000.00 but not exceeding P40,000.00.

This fixes the range of penalties for serious charges, within which the Court calibrated its sanction.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held the judge guilty of gross ignorance of the law. The law required him to decide on the evidence presented, to conduct a hearing, and to decide within ten days from filing. He did none of these. The thirty-nine petitioners never attended any scheduled hearing, so they presented no evidence. His personal interviews were not a hearing, for a hearing means that a party is given the chance to adduce evidence to support his side. The minutes showed only a superficial and mechanical inquiry into age, citizenship, and residence, without oath and without proof of residence, and without notice to counsel. The petitions were filed before April 17, yet the order came only on May 9, beyond the ten-day period, and its release two days before the election effectively deprived the complainants of their right to appeal.

On the second issue, the Court held him guilty of grave misconduct. He granted the petitions of the thirty-four despite their absence and failure to present evidence, while dismissing the petitions of the Mercado supporters who were absent. He issued the order without furnishing the complainants a copy, after misleading them that no such order existed. The Court reiterated that litigants are entitled to nothing less than the cold neutrality of an impartial judge, and that judges must render decisions free of any suspicion as to their fairness, impartiality, and integrity.

On the third issue, the Court held the recommended 5,000-peso fine incommensurate. Gross ignorance of the law and gross misconduct are serious charges, and the range for serious charges runs from suspension of more than three but not exceeding six months, to a fine of more than 20,000 pesos but not exceeding 40,000 pesos. The Court deemed suspension for four months without salary and other benefits appropriate.

Doctrine

A petition for inclusion of voters must be heard, decided on the evidence presented, and decided within ten days from filing, all per Section 143 of the Omnibus Election Code. A personal interview of petitioners, conducted without notice to the parties and their counsel, without oath, and without proof, is not a hearing. A judge who issues an order of inclusion without hearing and beyond the ten-day period is guilty of gross ignorance of the law. A judge who grants petitions despite the petitioners' absence and failure to present evidence, while dismissing the petitions of the opposing side, and who issues the order surreptitiously after misleading the parties, is guilty of grave misconduct and violates the rule that a judge should so behave at all times as to promote public confidence in the integrity and impartiality of the judiciary. Litigants are entitled to nothing less than the cold neutrality of an impartial judge.

Disposition

The Court found Judge Hector F. Dysangco guilty of gross ignorance of the law and grave misconduct, suspended him for four months without salary and other benefits, warned him that a repetition would be dealt with more severely, and ordered a copy of the decision attached to his records.

Remember This

Memorize the line: a personal interview is not a hearing, and litigants are entitled to nothing less than the cold neutrality of an impartial judge. Examiners use this case on the requisites of Section 143 of the Omnibus Election Code and on the administrative liability of judges for gross ignorance of the law and grave misconduct.