MARICHELLE E. CRUZ VS. PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Cruz versus People of the Philippines
The Case
This is the case of Marichelle Cruz against the People of the Philippines. It is a criminal matter in which the accused, Marichelle Cruz, sought review of the adverse rulings against her, first before the Court of Appeals and then before the Supreme Court. The case matters to a reviewee not for any novel doctrine of criminal law, but for a hard procedural lesson: the right to appeal is not self-executing, and a petitioner who sleeps on the Court's directives loses the remedy altogether. The Supreme Court's resolution here is a study in the consequences of non-compliance with a lawful order of the court.
Procedural History
The case travelled from the trial court, through the Court of Appeals, and finally to the Supreme Court. The decision text before us, however, speaks only of the last stage. What the record shows is that Marichelle Cruz filed a petition for review with the Court of Appeals, docketed as a criminal case, seeking relief from the judgment rendered against her below. The Court of Appeals, by a resolution dated the twelfth of April, two thousand fourteen, directed the petitioner to comply with certain requirements. The petitioner received that resolution but filed no compliance. The Court of Appeals then issued a resolution on the twelfth of January, two thousand fifteen, noting that its case management information system reflected no compliance from the petitioner despite her receipt of the earlier resolution. On that ground, the Court of Appeals deemed the petition abandoned and dismissed it. The matter then reached the Supreme Court, which issued its own resolution on the twenty-first of January, two thousand fifteen, through its Third Division.
Facts
Marichelle Cruz was the accused in a criminal case before the trial court. After the trial court ruled against her, she elevated the matter to the Court of Appeals by way of a petition for review. Her petition, however, was not complete or was not accompanied by the required submissions, and so the Court of Appeals issued a resolution dated the twelfth of April, two thousand fourteen, requiring her to comply.
The petitioner received that resolution. She did not comply. The case management information system of the Court of Appeals recorded that no compliance was ever filed. Seeing this, the Court of Appeals issued a resolution on the twelfth of January, two thousand fifteen, noting the absence of compliance and deeming the petition abandoned.
The Supreme Court, in turn, took up the matter and issued its resolution on the twenty-first of January, two thousand fifteen. The resolution simply quoted the Court of Appeals' action and noted it, with the Executive Clerk of Court transmitting the same to the parties.
Issues
- Whether or not the Court of Appeals correctly dismissed the petition for review on the ground that the petitioner failed to comply with its resolution despite receipt thereof.
- Whether or not the petitioner's failure to comply with the Court's directive warranted the deemed abandonment and dismissal of her petition.
Applicable Provisions
The decision text before us does not quote any statutory or rules provision. It rests entirely on the Court of Appeals' own resolution and the Supreme Court's noting of it. The operative language of the Court of Appeals, as quoted in the Supreme Court's resolution, is this:
The Court of Appeals case management information system verification entry showing that no compliance has been filed by petitioner despite receipt of Resolution dated April 12, 2014 is NOTED. In view thereof, the Petition is deemed ABANDONED and accordingly DISMISSED.
This language is the entire basis of the dismissal, and it bears on the case because it shows that the dismissal rested on the petitioner's own inaction, not on any ruling on the merits of her appeal.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court resolved that the Court of Appeals acted correctly. The petitioner had received the resolution of the twelfth of April, two thousand fourteen, and had filed no compliance. The case management information system confirmed this. The Court of Appeals was therefore justified in treating the petition as abandoned.
On the second issue, the Court held that the failure to comply with a lawful directive of the court warranted the dismissal of the petition. The Court quoted the Court of Appeals' resolution with approval:
In view thereof, the Petition is deemed ABANDONED and accordingly DISMISSED.
The Supreme Court noted this resolution and thereby sustained it. The reasoning is straightforward: a petition for review is a privilege, not a right, and it is pursued only by a litigant who follows the rules and the orders of the court. A petitioner who receives an order and does nothing has effectively abandoned her cause.
Doctrine
The rule a Bar candidate must retain is this: the right to appeal is statutory and must be exercised in the manner and within the period fixed by law and the Rules of Court. A petitioner who fails to comply with a resolution of the appellate court, despite receipt thereof, is deemed to have abandoned the petition, and the court may dismiss it. Non-compliance with a lawful court order is a ground for dismissal, and the dismissal is not a ruling on the merits but a consequence of the petitioner's own default. The case also teaches that the court's case management information system records are a sufficient basis for the court to act on non-compliance.
Disposition
The Supreme Court noted and sustained the Court of Appeals' dismissal. The petition of Marichelle Cruz was deemed abandoned and dismissed, and she lost her appeal.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a petition deemed abandoned for failure to comply with the court's resolution is dismissed, and the dismissal stands. Examiners like to use this case to test whether a candidate understands that procedural rules on appeal are mandatory and that non-compliance, not the merits, can end a litigant's case.