🎧 Case Brief Lecture

PRECY A. BUNYI-LABAO, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT, VS. MIRSA P. LABAO AND FRANCIS RODNICK B. CRUZ, DEFENDANTS-APPELLEES.

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Bunyi-Labao versus Labao

The Case

This is a case about a widow who was shut out of court on a technicality, and who asked the Supreme Court to open the door again. Precy Bunyi-Labao, the surviving spouse of Ruben Labao, sued Mirsa Labao and Francis Rodnick Cruz to nullify the torrens titles over a parcel of land in Taguig City, claiming that she, and not Mirsa, is the rightful heir of her deceased husband. The trial court dismissed her complaint, holding that she had committed forum shopping because she had earlier tried, and failed, to intervene in a separate case involving the same land. The Supreme Court disagreed. The case matters because it draws a bright line between a judgment on the merits, which can bar a later suit, and a mere preliminary order denying intervention, which cannot. It is a staple in remedial law examinations on forum shopping and res judicata.

Procedural History

Precy Bunyi-Labao filed her complaint for nullification of title before the Regional Trial Court of Pasig City, Branch 266. The defendant Mirsa Labao moved to dismiss on two grounds: that the complaint failed to state a cause of action, and that the plaintiff had violated the rule against forum shopping. The defendant Cruz, for his part, answered and filed a cross-claim against Mirsa, asserting that he was a purchaser in good faith and for value. The plaintiff then moved to amend her complaint to include the nullification of the later title issued in Cruz's name. The trial court admitted the amended complaint and found that it sufficiently stated a cause of action, but nonetheless dismissed it with prejudice on the ground of forum shopping. The plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court under Rule 41 of the Rules of Court, and the Supreme Court granted the petition, ordering the trial court to reinstate the complaint.

Facts

Spouses Ruben Labao and Gloria Factor were the registered owners of a parcel of land in Tipas, Taguig City, covered by Original Certificate of Title Number 9445-0053 issued by the Register of Deeds of the Province of Rizal. Gloria died. Ruben then contracted a subsequent marriage with Precy Bunyi-Labao on 31 May 2002. On 10 November 2002, Ruben died.

On 18 July 2003, Mirsa Labao executed an affidavit of self-adjudication declaring herself to be the sole heir of Ruben. On the strength of that affidavit, the original certificate of title was cancelled and Transfer Certificate of Title Number 42351 was issued on 9 October 2003 in the name of Mirsa Labao. Mirsa then sold the property to Francis Rodnick Cruz for 700,000 pesos. That title was cancelled and replaced by Transfer Certificate of Title Number 43 on 24 February 2004 in the name of Cruz.

On 6 August 2009, Precy filed a complaint for nullification of title, insisting that she is the sole heir of her husband Ruben and not Mirsa. Earlier, she had filed a motion for intervention in a separate case involving the same property, and that motion had been denied on the ground that she had no interest over the subject property. It was this earlier denial that the trial court used to dismiss her complaint for forum shopping.

Issues

  • Whether or not the trial court erred in dismissing the amended complaint on the ground of forum shopping.
  • Whether or not the denial of a motion for intervention is a judgment on the merits that can operate as res judicata and bar a subsequent independent action.

Applicable Provisions

Section 1 of Rule 19 of the Rules of Court, on intervention, provides:

Section 1. Who may intervene. A person who has a legal interest in the matter in litigation, or in the success of either of the parties, or an interest against both, or is so situated as to be adversely affected by a distribution or other disposition of property in the custody of the court or of an officer thereof may, with leave of court, be allowed to intervene in the action. The court shall consider whether or not the intervention will unduly delay or prejudice the adjudication of the rights of the original parties, and whether or not the intervenor's rights may be fully protected in a separate proceeding.

This provision is the pivot of the case: the denial of intervention rests on the requirement of a legal interest, and the Court held that such a denial is a preliminary determination, not a full adjudication of rights.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court ruled in the affirmative and held that the plaintiff was not guilty of forum shopping. Forum shopping requires three elements: identity of parties, or at least parties representing the same interests in both actions; identity of the rights asserted and the relief prayed for, the relief being founded on the same facts; and identity of these two particulars such that any judgment rendered in the other action will, regardless of which party is successful, amount to res judicata in the action under consideration. The Court held that the third element was missing, because the denial of the motion for intervention in the earlier case could not operate as res judicata.

On the second issue, the Court held that the denial of the motion for intervention was not a judgment on the merits. The Court defined a judgment on the merits as one rendered after argument and investigation, and when there is a determination of which party is right, as distinguished from a judgment rendered upon some preliminary or formal or merely technical point, or by default and without trial. It is one wherein there is an unequivocal determination of the rights and obligations of the parties with respect to the causes of action and the subject matter of the case. The Court quoted its earlier ruling in Cruz versus Court of Appeals:

Res judicata applies only where judgment on the merits is finally rendered on the first complaint. It does not apply if no trial has been held yet on the first complaint. A judgment on the merits presupposes that trial has been conducted, evidence presented, and issues sufficiently heard and passed upon. It is a judgment rendered after a determination of which party is right, as distinguished from a judgment rendered upon some preliminary or formal technical point.

The Court explained that the denial of the motion for intervention was a preliminary action based on Section 1 of Rule 19, which requires a legal interest in the matter in litigation before a person may be allowed to intervene. It was not a judgment in which the parties, including the plaintiff, were given full opportunity to present their respective evidence and arguments. It was not a full adjudication of the rights of the parties, but merely a preliminary finding that the plaintiff had no interest in the subject property. Hence, it could not bar the filing of the complaint. The Court also cited Asuncion versus Pineda, where it held that when a motion for intervention is denied, the movant does not become a party to the case, and the order denying intervention is not a decision on the merits and does not constitute res judicata. With the denial of her motion for intervention, it was the plaintiff's right to pursue her case in a separate action to protect her rights over the subject property. She did not avail herself of several judicial remedies in different courts in the hope of increasing her chances of obtaining a favorable judgment.

Doctrine

A candidate should retain these rules. First, forum shopping exists only when the three elements concur: identity of parties, identity of rights asserted and relief prayed for founded on the same facts, and identity of these particulars such that any judgment in the other action would amount to res judicata in the action under consideration. Second, res judicata requires a former judgment that is final, on the merits, rendered by a court with jurisdiction over the subject matter and the parties, and with identity of parties, subject matter, and cause of action between the first and second actions. Third, a judgment on the merits is one rendered after argument and investigation, with an unequivocal determination of the rights and obligations of the parties, as distinguished from a judgment on a preliminary, formal, or technical point. Fourth, the denial of a motion for intervention under Section 1 of Rule 19 is a preliminary determination of the movant's legal interest, not a judgment on the merits, and therefore cannot operate as res judicata or bar a subsequent independent action.

Disposition

The Supreme Court granted the petition, set aside the dismissal, and ordered the trial court to reinstate the complaint.

Remember This

The single line to memorize: the denial of a motion for intervention is not a judgment on the merits and cannot operate as res judicata, so it cannot make the movant guilty of forum shopping. Examiners use this case to test the elements of forum shopping and res judicata, and the distinction between a preliminary order and a judgment on the merits.