🎧 Case Brief Lecture

LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES, INC., ROBERTO P. LAUREL AND POMPEYO B. ADAMOS, PETITIONERS, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, CARMELITA C. CRISOLOGO, NANCY M. POBLETE AND SHIR…

← Read the full text of the decision

Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.

Lyceum of the Philippines versus National Labor Relations Commission

The Case

This is a labor case about three school physicians whom Lyceum of the Philippines dismissed on the ground of redundancy after it engaged a job contractor to run its school clinic. The physicians complained of illegal dismissal. The Labor Arbiter ruled for them, the National Labor Relations Commission affirmed, and Lyceum went to the Supreme Court insisting that contracting out services is a valid management prerogative. The case matters because it fixes the four requisites of a valid redundancy program and shows how the Court treats a contracting arrangement that is really labor-only contracting in disguise.

Procedural History

Carmelita Crisologo and Nancy Poblete filed their complaint for illegal dismissal before the Labor Arbiter in November 2003, and Shirley Ann Codamon filed hers in December 2003. On September 21, 2004, the Labor Arbiter rendered a decision finding Lyceum guilty of illegal dismissal and ordering the reinstatement of the three physicians without loss of seniority rights, with full backwages, service incentive leave pay, vacation and sick leave pay, and attorney's fees equivalent to ten percent of the judgment award. Lyceum appealed to the National Labor Relations Commission. The Commission affirmed the Labor Arbiter in a Resolution issued on September 28, 2005, and denied Lyceum's motion for reconsideration in a Resolution issued on November 21, 2005. Lyceum then filed a petition for certiorari before the Supreme Court, alleging grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction.

Facts

The private respondents were physicians who served the school clinic of Lyceum of the Philippines. They worked part-time, on daily shifts of four and one half hours from Monday to Friday and shorter hours on Saturdays. Crisologo received a monthly salary of 15,937.15 pesos, Poblete received 15,067.85 pesos, and Codamon received 15,647.30 pesos. Their appointment letters were issued intermittently through the years, but they served continuously.

In the latter part of 2003, Lyceum engaged the services of a job contractor to provide medical personnel for its students and employees, effective February 1, 2004. On December 18, 2003, the three physicians received letters informing them that their employment would be terminated effective January 31, 2004, allegedly due to redundancy. Lyceum offered to pay separation pay of one month salary, proportionate, for every year of service, plus cash conversion of leave credits.

The physicians challenged the dismissal. Before the Labor Arbiter, Lyceum submitted comparative cost data to show that contracting out was cheaper. The data showed the opposite: the cost of contracting appeared to exceed the cost of keeping the regular physicians. The physicians also showed that the entity introduced as the independent contractor was not duly registered as such, so it was presumed to be engaged in labor-only contracting.

Issues

  • Whether or not the termination of the private respondents on the ground of redundancy was valid and justified.
  • Whether or not the contracting out of the clinic services was a valid exercise of management prerogative that the National Labor Relations Commission should not disturb.
  • Whether or not the award of attorney's fees had factual basis.

Applicable Provisions

The decision applies the statutory concept of redundancy as an authorized cause of termination under the Labor Code. The Court describes it in these terms:

Redundancy, as one of the authorized causes for the termination of employment by the employer, exists where the services of an employee are in excess of what is reasonably demanded by the actual requirement of the enterprise.

This definition controls the first issue, because Lyceum had to show that the physicians' positions were truly superfluous to the needs of the enterprise.

The decision also states the requisites for a valid redundancy program, which every employer must satisfy:

However, for the implementation of a redundancy program to be valid, the employer must comply with the following requisites: written notice served on both the employees and the DOLE at least one month prior to the intended date of retrenchment; payment of separation pay equivalent to at least one month pay or at least one month pay for every year of service, whichever is higher; good faith in abolishing the redundant positions; and fair and reasonable criteria in ascertaining what positions are to be declared redundant and accordingly abolished.

These requisites frame the Court's inquiry into whether Lyceum's program was genuine or a pretext.

Finally, the decision identifies the criteria for selecting redundant positions:

The criteria in ascertaining what positions are to be declared redundant, are preferred status, efficiency and seniority.

This standard tests whether the employer chose positions fairly rather than arbitrarily.

Ruling

On the first issue, the Court held that the dismissal was illegal. Lyceum's stated reason was its decision to engage an independent contractor to man the school clinic. But Lyceum failed to establish that the decision to contract out the physicians' functions was intended as a cost-cutting or streamlining device. The comparative cost data it submitted actually showed that contracting cost more than continued employment of regular physicians, belying the alleged purpose. The termination therefore violated the physicians' security of tenure.

The Court also held that the physicians were regular employees because of the length of their employment and the necessity and desirability of their functions as school physicians. The intermittent issuance of appointment letters during their employment was of no moment.

On the second issue, the Court rejected the management prerogative argument. The entity introduced as the independent contractor was not duly registered as such, so it was presumed to be engaged in labor-only contracting, which is not covered by the policy on permissible contracting. Contracting out, in other words, cannot be used to defeat the right to security of tenure.

On the third issue, the Court sustained the award of attorney's fees equivalent to ten percent of the total award, because the physicians had secured the service of counsel to pursue their valid claims. It disallowed moral and exemplary damages for lack of a clear showing of bad faith.

Doctrine

A Bar candidate should retain these rules. First, redundancy exists where the services of an employee are in excess of what is reasonably demanded by the actual requirement of the enterprise. Second, for a redundancy program to be valid, the employer must comply with four requisites: written notice to both the employees and the Department of Labor and Employment at least one month before the intended date of retrenchment; payment of separation pay equivalent to at least one month pay or at least one month pay for every year of service, whichever is higher; good faith in abolishing the redundant positions; and fair and reasonable criteria in ascertaining which positions are redundant, namely preferred status, efficiency and seniority. Third, contracting out services is a management prerogative, but it cannot be used as a pretext to circumvent security of tenure; where the contractor is not duly registered, it is presumed to be engaged in labor-only contracting. Fourth, length of service and the necessity of the functions make an employee regular, regardless of intermittent appointment letters.

Disposition

The Supreme Court dismissed the petition for lack of merit and affirmed the Decision of the National Labor Relations Commission, which had sustained the Labor Arbiter's finding of illegal dismissal and the awards of reinstatement, backwages, leave pay and attorney's fees.

Remember This

Memorize the four requisites of a valid redundancy program, and remember that contracting out cannot be a shield for labor-only contracting or a pretext to remove regular employees. Examiners use this case to test redundancy requisites and the limits of management prerogative in contracting arrangements.