THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND PRESIDENT OF QUEDAN AND RURAL CREDIT GUARANTEE CORPORATION, PETITIONERS, VS. EMPLOYEES OF QUEDAN AND RURAL CREDIT GUARANTEE CORPORATION AND QUEZON CIT…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Quedan and Rural Credit Guarantee Corporation versus Employees of Quedan and Rural Credit Guarantee Corporation
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari brought by the Board of Directors and the President of the Quedan and Rural Credit Guarantee Corporation, commonly called Quedancor, against the Employees of Quedancor. Quedancor asks the Supreme Court to annul the orders of two branches of the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City which granted a writ of preliminary injunction restraining the implementation of the corporation's 2010 Rationalization Plan. The case matters because it is the Court's clearest recent statement on the requisites for a writ of preliminary injunction, and on the narrow, preservative role that such a writ plays while the principal case is still pending.
Procedural History
The Employees of Quedancor filed a petition in the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City, Branch 217, seeking a declaration that the 2010 Rationalization Plan was illegal and void, with a prayer for a writ of preliminary injunction and a temporary restraining order. The trial court issued a twenty-day temporary restraining order, and later, in its July 2012 Order, granted the writ of preliminary injunction upon a bond of 200,000 pesos. Quedancor moved for reconsideration. The presiding judge of Branch 217 inhibited himself, and the case was re-raffled to Branch 96, which denied the motion for reconsideration in its February 2013 Resolution. Quedancor then went to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari under Rule 65, with an application for a temporary restraining order. The Supreme Court earlier denied that application, and later decided the petition on the merits.
Facts
Quedancor is an attached agency of the Department of Agriculture, created under Republic Act Number 7393 to provide a credit-support mechanism and guarantee system to workers and small enterprises in the countryside. In 2010, pursuant to Executive Order Number 366, it formulated a Rationalization Plan which reduced authorized permanent plantilla positions from 451 to 191, and abolished 502 contractual and 636 casual positions. The Department of Budget and Management approved the plan in January 2010, to be implemented within two months.
The 177 private respondents had served Quedancor for ten to twenty years, either as contractual or casual employees, and were among those affected. In May 2010 they filed their petition for declaration of nullity, alleging that the plan violated Republic Act Number 7393, Executive Order Number 366, and their constitutional right to security of tenure. They stressed the urgency of implementation, since the President of Quedancor had already begun a reorganization that would displace 658 of 849 employees.
During the injunction hearings the parties agreed to maintain the status quo: Quedancor could continue the program, but could not terminate or transfer the petitioning employees, nor send them notices of abolition. Later, however, Quedancor adopted a Board Resolution increasing the plantilla back to 451, and its new officer-in-charge began dismissing employees. This prompted the Employees to move for resolution of their pending application, and the trial court granted the writ.
Issues
- Whether or not the Regional Trial Court committed grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction in issuing the writ of preliminary injunction in favor of the Employees of Quedancor.
- Whether or not the issuance of the writ prematurely prejudged the merits of the main case for declaration of nullity of the 2010 Rationalization Plan.
Applicable Provisions
Section 3, Article XIII of the 1987 Constitution provides:
The State shall afford full protection to labor, local and overseas, organized and unorganized, and promote full employment and equality of employment opportunities for all.
This is the substantive right to security of tenure that the Employees invoked and that the trial court found to exist prima facie.
Section 28 of Republic Act Number 7393 provides:
In view of the expanded scope of the operations of the Corporation, it is hereby authorized to reorganize and expand its personnel complement, in consultation with the Civil Service Commission and in accordance with Section 14 hereof, in order to achieve the efficiency and effectiveness in the delivery of its mandated services.
This is the authority Quedancor relied upon for its reorganization, and its limits were among the matters pending before the trial court.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petition fails to persuade. Appellate courts do not generally interfere with the trial court's exercise of sound judicial discretion in injunctive matters, except where there is grave abuse of discretion, which means a capricious and whimsical exercise of judgment equivalent to lack of jurisdiction. The burden is on the petitioner to prove not merely reversible error, but grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction. Mere abuse of discretion is not enough; it must be grave.
The Court restated the nature of the remedy and its requisites:
A writ of preliminary injunction will be issued only upon showing that the right to be protected exists prima facie, the acts sought to be enjoined are violative of that right, and the violation sought to be prevented would cause an irreparable injustice.
All three were present. The Employees had served for ten to twenty years and alleged a corporate tradition of automatic renewal of contracts. The Court stressed that while a clear showing of the right is necessary, its existence need not be conclusively established; the evidence required need only be a sampling intended to give the court an idea of the justification for the writ, pending decision on the merits. The Court also agreed that implementation of the Board Resolution increasing the plantilla to 451 was premature, since it was still under review by the Office of the President and would still require a new rationalization plan and fresh approval by the Department of Budget and Management.
On the second issue, the Court held that the writ did not prejudge the main case. Its findings were premised solely on initial evidence and were merely provisional or interlocutory. The writ would amount to a prejudgment only if it granted the main prayer of the complaint, leaving nothing for the court to try except incidental matters, which was not the situation here. The Court clarified that its discussion applied only to the propriety of the writ and did not affect the merits, and that the legality of the plan and the alleged non-renewal of contracts should be ventilated at trial.
Doctrine
A writ of preliminary injunction is a preservative remedy, merely temporary, resorted to only when there is a pressing necessity to avoid injurious consequences that cannot be remedied under any standard of compensation. It issues only upon a clear showing of three requisites: a prima facie right, acts violative of that right, and irreparable injustice. The right need not be conclusively established; the evidence need only be a sampling. Certiorari will lie against the grant of a writ only for grave abuse of discretion, never for mere error. And a writ does not prejudge the main case unless it grants the main prayer, leaving nothing to try but incidental matters.
Disposition
The petition was denied, and the July 2012 Order and February 2013 Resolution of the Regional Trial Court were affirmed. The Employees of Quedancor won.
Remember This
Memorize the three requisites of a writ of preliminary injunction and the rule that the right need only be shown prima facie, by evidence that is a mere sampling. Examiners use this case on provisional remedies, on the standard of grave abuse of discretion in injunctive orders, and on the distinction between an interlocutory writ and a prejudgment of the merits.