FELICIDAD V. MORALES, PETITIONER, VS. JULIO G. TARONGOY, DEPUTY SHERIFF, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT, BRANCH 19, PAGADIAN CITY, ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Morales versus Tarongoy
The Case
This is an administrative case in which Felicidad Morales, a prevailing party in a labor case, charged Deputy Sheriff Julio Tarongoy of the Regional Trial Court of Pagadian City with grave misconduct and violation of the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act in connection with his implementation of a final judgment of the National Labor Relations Commission. The case matters because it fixes the standard of conduct for sheriffs in executing writs: the sheriff must verify the value of the property he levies, must not demand unauthorized fees, and must answer the orders of the Supreme Court. It is also a study in how silence and defiance of Court resolutions are treated as admission and as grounds for the severest administrative penalty.
Procedural History
The case began as a verified complaint filed directly with the Supreme Court against a deputy sheriff, an officer of a lower court, so it was an original administrative action and not an appeal. The Court required the respondent to comment on the complaint, but he did not comply. The Court then required him to show cause why he should not be disciplinarily dealt with for ignoring the earlier resolution, and again he did not respond, although the resolutions were duly sent and acknowledged. The Office of the Court Administrator evaluated the case and recommended suspension for three months without pay, with a warning. The Court, noting a prior finding of negligence against the same sheriff in an earlier administrative case, where he was fined an amount equivalent to one month's salary with a warning, resolved the case itself and imposed the penalty of dismissal.
Facts
On 27 January 1992, the National Labor Relations Commission rendered a decision ordering the employer, Ever Cinema Theatre, to pay Felicidad Morales and a fellow employee the amount of 190,254 pesos. The employer evaded payment, so Labor Arbiter Dominador Almirante issued an alias writ of execution directing the Provincial Sheriff of Pagadian City to collect the sum adjudged or to satisfy the judgment by levying movable and immovable property of the employer not exempt from execution. Morales personally handcarried the writ to Pagadian City.
Respondent Sheriff demanded a 15,000 peso fee for implementing the writ. Having no cash on hand, and eager to have the writ promptly effected, Morales borrowed a portion of the sum demanded and gave it to him. The Sheriff then levied two parcels of real property owned by the employer. After the required publication, and only three days before the scheduled auction sale, he informed Morales that she would have to put up a bond because the levied properties were mortgaged with a bank. She questioned him for levying mortgaged assets when there were eleven other parcels of land registered in the employer's name that were not similarly encumbered.
The records showed that the two levied parcels were mortgaged with Metrobank for 2,000,000 pesos and with the Philippine National Bank for 7,000,000 pesos, against a money judgment of only 190,000 pesos. The Sheriff had also been found negligent in an earlier administrative case and fined an amount equivalent to one month's salary, with a warning.
Issues
- Whether or not respondent Sheriff is guilty of grave misconduct for levying real property that was mortgaged and of insufficient value to satisfy the judgment, and for failing to levy other unencumbered properties of the employer.
- Whether or not respondent Sheriff may be held liable for demanding and collecting a fee for the implementation of the writ without submitting the amount for the approval of the court as a bill of costs.
- Whether or not respondent Sheriff's repeated failure to comply with the resolutions of the Supreme Court constitutes defiance and an implied admission of the charges, warranting the penalty of dismissal.
Applicable Provisions
The decision refers to Republic Act Number 3019, the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act, as the statute invoked by the complainant:
Republic Act No. 3019, also known as the Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act.
This is the law under which the complainant charged the Sheriff, and it frames the seriousness of demanding unauthorized fees in the execution of a writ.
The decision also invokes the rule that sheriffs are allowed to collect a sheriff's fee in the implementation of writs, but only through the proper procedure:
Under the law, sheriffs are allowed to collect Sheriff's fee in the implementation of the writ.
This provision bears on the case because the Court held that the complaint would have been avoided had the Sheriff required the prevailing party to submit to the court for approval the amount necessary, as a bill of costs, to enforce the writ.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court found the charge of grave misconduct meritorious. The money judgment was only 190,000 pesos, yet the Sheriff levied properties mortgaged for 2,000,000 pesos and 7,000,000 pesos. He should have verified the value of the real property levied and checked whether it was free from liens or encumbrances. If the market value of the real estate would only cover the mortgage loan, then the levy is useless. Moreover, there were other properties of the employer that were not levied upon. The Sheriff failed to discharge his duties with prudence, caution, and attention.
On the second issue, the Court recognized that expenses are incurred in the execution of writs and that sheriffs are allowed to collect a sheriff's fee. But the proper course was to require the prevailing party to submit to the court for approval the amount necessary to enforce the writ, as a bill of costs. The complaint would have been avoided had the Sheriff done so.
On the third issue, the Court held that the Sheriff's continued disregard of its resolutions was indicative of guilt and a plain defiance that cannot be countenanced. Having been given an opportunity to defend himself and having failed to comply with two Court resolutions despite proof of receipt, he is deemed to have admitted the charges. Considering his prior finding of negligence, the Court was constrained to order his dismissal from the service.
Doctrine
A sheriff executing a writ must act with prudence, caution, and attention. He must verify the value of the property levied and check whether it is free from liens or encumbrances; a levy on property whose market value merely covers an existing mortgage is useless and constitutes grave misconduct. A sheriff may collect a sheriff's fee, but the amount necessary to enforce the writ must be submitted to the court for approval as a bill of costs; demanding a fee directly from the prevailing party is improper. Finally, a respondent's repeated failure to comply with Court resolutions, despite due notice, is an implied admission of the charges and a defiance of the Court that warrants the severest administrative penalty, especially where there is a prior record of negligence.
Disposition
The Court found respondent Sheriff guilty of grave misconduct and ordered his dismissal from the service, with forfeiture of all benefits, including leave credits and retirement benefits, and with prejudice to re-employment in any branch or service of the government, including any government owned and controlled corporation.
Remember This
The single line worth memorizing is that a sheriff who levies property already encumbered beyond its value, and who defies the orders of the Supreme Court, commits grave misconduct punishable by dismissal. Examiners use this case to test the duties of a sheriff in execution, the proper procedure for collecting sheriff's fees through a bill of costs, and the rule that unexplained defiance of Court resolutions is an implied admission of guilt.