GEPTE M. PEREZ, COMPLAINANT, VS. MARIA ISABEL D. HILARIO, SOCIAL WORKER II, REGIONAL TRIAL COURT OF PASAY CITY, BRANCH 113, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Perez versus Hilario
The Case
This is an administrative case brought by Gepte M. Perez, a Court Stenographer of the Regional Trial Court of Pasay City, against Maria Isabel D. Hilario, a Court Social Worker of the same court, for non-payment of a just debt. It began as a sworn letter-complaint filed directly with the Office of the Court Administrator, and it matters because it fixes the rule that a complainant's withdrawal of an administrative complaint does not erase the respondent's administrative liability, and because it illustrates how the Civil Service rules classify and penalize the willful failure to pay a just debt.
Procedural History
The complaint was filed with the Office of the Court Administrator on October 12, 2001. The Office directed Ms. Hilario to comment on November 15, 2001. On December 14, 2001, after Ms. Hilario had fully paid the sum owing, Perez withdrew his complaint. Ms. Hilario then wrote to the Office on December 19, 2001, asking that the case be closed or dismissed since the account had been settled. The Office submitted a memorandum to the Supreme Court recommending that the matter be considered closed and terminated. The case thus reached the Supreme Court as an administrative matter, and the Court resolved it by decision.
Facts
On November 9, 1998, Ms. Hilario borrowed 3,000 pesos from Mr. Perez, promising to repay it immediately. She did not. She kept putting him off each time he asked for payment. On April 5, 2001, she executed a promissory note to pay her debt within six months from that date.
Sometime in the first week of July 2001, she paid 500 pesos, but made no payments thereafter despite continuous demand and reminders. On October 12, 2001, Perez filed a sworn complaint with the Office of the Court Administrator, praying for whatever administrative penalty might be meted out on her.
On December 14, 2001, after Ms. Hilario had fully paid the sum owing, Perez withdrew his complaint. Ms. Hilario then asked that the case be closed or dismissed. The Office noted that since the promissory note gave six months from its date and the debt was fully paid on December 14, 2001, the delay was only a little over a month, and it recommended that the matter be considered closed and terminated. The Court, however, observed that this was the second case of this nature involving Ms. Hilario, who had earlier been reprimanded for similar shortcomings.
Issues
- Whether or not Ms. Hilario is administratively liable for willful failure to pay a just debt.
- Whether or not the complainant's withdrawal of the complaint and the respondent's subsequent full payment relieve her of administrative liability.
- Whether or not the penalty recommended by the Office of the Court Administrator, which was to consider the matter closed and terminated, is the correct penalty.
Applicable Provisions
Book Five, Section 46 of the Revised Administrative Code of 1987 provides:
Section 46. Discipline: General Provisions. - (a) No officer or employee in the Civil Service shall be suspended or dismissed except for cause as provided by law and after due process. (b) The following shall be grounds for disciplinary action: … (22) Willful failure to pay just debts or willful failure to pay taxes to the government; xxx
This is the substantive ground for the charge against Ms. Hilario, since her admitted failure to pay a just debt falls squarely within the enumerated grounds for disciplinary action.
Rule Fourteen, Section 22 of the Omnibus Rules of the Civil Service defines just debts in this wise:
claims adjudicated by a court of law, or claims the existence and justness of which are admitted by the debtor.
This definition is decisive because Ms. Hilario never denied the existence and justness of the debt, bringing it within the second kind of just debt.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that Ms. Hilario is administratively liable. In her comment she did not deny incurring the debt, much less the fact that it was a just debt. She also did not deny her failure to pay it when due. In the light of her admissions, the provision of the Revised Administrative Code applies.
On the second issue, the Court held that the withdrawal of the complaint did not relieve her of her administrative culpability. Proceedings against a public officer or employee for misconduct, malfeasance, or misfeasance cannot just be withdrawn anytime by the complainant, nor should they depend on the complainant's whims and caprices. The complainant is, in a real sense, only a witness therein. His purpose was not only to collect from Ms. Hilario but also to seek administrative disciplinary action against her. The penalty is therefore not directed at her private life but at her actuation unbecoming a public employee.
On the third issue, the Court held that the recommended closure was not the correct penalty. Under Rule Fourteen, Section 22 of the Omnibus Rules of the Civil Service, willful refusal to pay a just debt is a light offense, and the penalties are reprimand for the first offense, suspension from one to thirty days for the second offense, and dismissal from the service for the third offense. Since this was her second offense, she should be suspended and not merely reminded about the previous reprimand. Tempering the penalty in view of the present economic conditions of court employees, and noting that she did pay off her debt albeit with admitted delay, the Court fixed a suspension of five working days.
Doctrine
Willful failure to pay a just debt is a ground for disciplinary action under Book Five, Section 46 of the Revised Administrative Code of 1987. A debt is a just debt when it is a claim adjudicated by a court of law, or a claim the existence and justness of which are admitted by the debtor. Willful refusal to pay a just debt is a light offense under Rule Fourteen, Section 22 of the Omnibus Rules of the Civil Service, penalized by reprimand for the first offense, suspension from one to thirty days for the second offense, and dismissal from the service for the third offense. A complainant's withdrawal of an administrative complaint does not extinguish the respondent's administrative liability, because the complainant is in a real sense only a witness and the proceedings do not depend on his whims and caprices.
Disposition
Ms. Hilario was suspended for five working days for conduct unbecoming a public servant by first refusing and then failing to pay on time a just debt, with a stern warning that a repetition of the same or similar acts would be dealt with more severely.
Remember This
Memorize the line that the complainant in an administrative case is in a real sense only a witness, so withdrawal never erases liability. Examiners use this case to test the classification of willful failure to pay a just debt as a light offense and the graduated penalties for first, second, and third offenses.