ELISEO F. SORIANO AND MEMBERS CHURCH OF GOD INTERNATIONAL, PETITIONERS, VS. IGLESIA NI CRISTO, MARIANITO CAYAO, JR., ALFIE ANGELES, CRISANTHI LINTAG, MICHAEL SANDOVAL, RAMIL PAR…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Soriano versus Iglesia ni Cristo
The Case
This is Soriano versus Iglesia ni Cristo, a petition for injunction with a prayer for a temporary restraining order and a writ of preliminary injunction, filed directly with the Supreme Court by Eliseo Soriano, the presiding minister of the Members Church of God International, against the Iglesia ni Cristo, several of its ministers and hosts, and its broadcast entities and radio and television stations. Soriano asked the Court to stop the respondents from inciting the Muslim community and other religious groups to take up arms and commit acts of terrorism against him and his church, and from airing the programs he blamed for that incitement. The case matters far less for the religious quarrel at its center than for what it teaches about jurisdiction: a litigant cannot walk straight into the Supreme Court with an ordinary action for injunction, no matter how urgent or how grave the danger he alleges.
Procedural History
The petitioners filed the petition directly with the Supreme Court on 23 February 2005. No complaint was first filed in a trial court, and the case passed through no Court of Appeals. On 28 April 2005 the petitioners filed an extremely urgent ex parte motion to resolve their application for a temporary restraining order and a writ of preliminary injunction. The Court denied that application on 9 March 2006. The respondents filed their comment on 5 April 2005. The Court then resolved the petition itself, and it dismissed the petition for lack of jurisdiction.
Facts
Soriano hosts the television program Ang Dating Daan, where he criticized what he called false doctrines, particularly those of the Iglesia ni Cristo. The Iglesia ni Cristo answered with its own television and radio programs. According to the petitioners, the hosts of those programs defamed and insulted Soriano with labels such as dayukdok, gutom, linta, manloloko, mandarambong, mangongotong and manhohostage, and aired edited, spliced and mangled audio and video clips imputing false acts to him.
The petitioners alleged that on 7 November 2003 the respondents used mangled audio tapes to make it appear that Soriano was defaming the Muslim faith, and tried to agitate the Muslim community to attack the Ang Dating Daan Convention Center and other Church of God coordinating centers. On 12 November 2003, in the program Ang Tamang Daan, respondent Sandoval and a certain Mr. Bularan imputed false statements to Soriano. On 18 November 2003 the same program presented angry sentiments from two members of the Muslim faith, and on 21 November 2003 a grenade was thrown at the Church of God Coordinating Center, which fortunately did not detonate. On 14 February 2005, in the program Dating Nasa Sumpa Ngayon Nasa Tama, respondents Cayao, Angeles and Lintag again imputed false statements to Soriano and incited Muslims to harm the petitioners. On 19 and 20 February 2005, in the radio program Mga Tinig sa Ilang, anonymous hosts and callers again incited the Muslim community to attack and assault the petitioners.
The respondents told a different story. They claimed that Soriano had attacked the Prophet Muhammad and called Muslims anti-Cristo, mamamatay tao and mamumugot ng ulo, and had for years insulted the Iglesia ni Cristo and its ministers. They said they merely answered back to uphold their doctrines and to expose his teachings and his statements against known religions.
Issues
- Whether or not the Supreme Court may take cognizance of a petition for injunction filed directly with it, seeking to restrain the respondents from inciting the Muslim community and other groups to harm the petitioners.
- Whether or not the broadcast entities and radio and television stations may be enjoined by the Supreme Court from airing the programs complained of.
Applicable Provisions
Section 9 of Batas Pambansa Blg. 129, the Judiciary Reorganization Act, defines the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeals and provides:
Section 9. Jurisdiction. – The Court of Appeals shall exercise: (1) Original jurisdiction to issue writs of mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, and quo warranto, and auxiliary writs or processes, whether or not in aid of its appellate jurisdiction; (2) Exclusive original jurisdiction over actions for annulment of judgments of Regional Trial Courts.
This fixes where the extraordinary writs and auxiliary processes belong, and it says nothing of an original action for injunction in the Supreme Court.
Section 2 of Rule 46 of the Revised Rules of Court, on cases originally filed before the Supreme Court, provides:
Section 2. To what actions applicable. – This Rule shall apply to original actions for certiorari, prohibition, mandamus and quo warranto.
This limits the original actions the Supreme Court may entertain, and an action for injunction is not among them.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court denied the petition for lack of jurisdiction. It began by characterizing the reliefs prayed for. The petitioners asked for a temporary restraining order, then a writ of preliminary injunction, and finally an order making the injunction permanent. That third prayer, the Court said, reveals that the case is an action for injunction, over which the Court has no jurisdiction. The Court distinguished the main action for injunction from the provisional remedy: the main action seeks a judgment embodying a final injunction, while the preliminary injunction merely preserves the status quo until the merits can be heard. Because the petition sought a permanent injunction, it was a main action, and it should have been brought before the appropriate Regional Trial Court. The Court cited its holding that an injunction is a civil action in which the subject of litigation is incapable of pecuniary estimation, so that the Regional Trial Court has exclusive original jurisdiction over it. It also rejected the petitioners' reliance on Manila Banking Corporation, noting that in that case the complaint for injunction was filed initially in a Court of First Instance, not in the Supreme Court.
On the second issue, the prayer to enjoin the broadcast entities and stations from airing the programs fell with the first. Since the Court could not take cognizance of the action for injunction at all, it could grant no relief against any of the respondents, whether the ministers or the broadcasting stations.
Doctrine
An action for injunction is a civil action incapable of pecuniary estimation, and exclusive original jurisdiction over it belongs to the Regional Trial Court. The Supreme Court's original jurisdiction is not open to it. Under the rules, the original actions that may be filed directly with the Supreme Court are limited to certiorari, prohibition, mandamus and quo warranto, and an action for injunction is not one of them. A litigant who prays for a permanent injunction thereby institutes a main action for injunction, and he cannot convert it into an original Supreme Court proceeding by adding prayers for a temporary restraining order and a writ of preliminary injunction, because those provisional remedies exist only as incidents of an independent action in the proper court. Urgency and the gravity of the alleged danger do not create jurisdiction.
Disposition
The petition was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction, and the respondents prevailed.
Remember This
The one line to memorize: an action for injunction, being incapable of pecuniary estimation, lies exclusively with the Regional Trial Court, and the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction extends only to certiorari, prohibition, mandamus and quo warranto. Examiners use this case to test jurisdiction over actions incapable of pecuniary estimation, and to trap students who think a prayer for a temporary restraining order lets a party leap straight to the Supreme Court.