BASES CONVERSION AND DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY, PETITIONER, VS. ROMEO S. CARIÑO, MARIA LORETA C. MORALES, ALEXANDER CARIÑO, CONSUELO C. BALLESTEROS, AND THE HEIRS OF SESENIO CARIÑO …
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Bases Conversion and Development Authority versus Cariño
The Case
This is a petition for certiorari filed by the Bases Conversion and Development Authority, the government agency that owns, holds, and administers the former American military reservations under the Bases Conversion and Development Act of 1992, against Romeo Cariño, Maria Loreta Morales, Alexander Cariño, Consuelo Ballesteros, and the heirs of Sesenio Cariño. The Cariño family sued the Authority in the Regional Trial Court of San Fernando, La Union, in a case for declaration of nullity of documents, recovery of possession, and, in the alternative, payment of just compensation and damages, over two cadastral lots they claim to have occupied as owners since time immemorial. The Authority moved to compel the family to pay additional docket fees, insisting that the action is capable of pecuniary estimation because it involves real property. The case matters because it fixes the test for classifying an action as one incapable of pecuniary estimation, and because it shows how the Supreme Court treats a trial court's ruling on docket fees under the standard of grave abuse of discretion.
Procedural History
The Cariño family filed the declaration of nullity case before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 66, San Fernando, La Union, in 2007. The Authority answered and later moved to direct the clerk of court to make a deficiency assessment, asking that the plaintiffs be ordered to pay the correct docket fees. In its order dated April 26, 2012, the trial court denied the motion, holding that the principal relief was the declaration of nullity of survey plans, tax declarations, and muniments, that the prayer for just compensation was merely incidental, and that the subject matter was incapable of pecuniary estimation, so that docket fees were properly computed under paragraph (b) of Section 7 of Rule 141 rather than paragraph (a). The trial court denied the Authority's motion for reconsideration in its order dated August 2, 2012. The Authority then went directly to the Supreme Court by petition for certiorari under Rule 65, imputing grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction to the trial court. The Cariño family failed to file a comment despite notice.
Facts
The Authority manages the Poro Point Special Economic and Freeport Zone and, in the course of that management, caused the survey of Cadastral Lot No. 50545, the land adjoining the Wallace Air Station. On July 4, 1997, the Department of Environment and Natural Resources approved that survey as SWO-01-003243. Several years later, the Cariño family filed a protest with the Department, claiming that they had possessed Cadastral Lot No. 50545 as owners since time immemorial, and asking that the survey approval be cancelled or corrected to include their names as survey claimants.
In 2007, the family instituted the declaration of nullity case, claiming ownership over portions of Cadastral Lot No. 6182 and Cadastral Lot No. 50545, with an aggregate assessed value of 104,770 pesos. They alleged that they inherited the properties from their late father, Januario Cariño, and that they and their predecessors had occupied the land continuously and openly as owners until the State took possession from them sometime in 2004 through force, stealth, and intimidation. They prayed for the nullification of the survey plans and of the tax declarations issued in the Authority's name, for a declaration that they are the owners, and for restoration of possession, or, in the alternative, for payment of just compensation, moral and exemplary damages, and attorney's fees.
In its answer, the Authority averred that Cadastral Lot No. 6182 is a United States military reservation and that Cadastral Lot No. 50545 is government property previously occupied by the Americans. It denied that the family ever possessed the land, noted that their private survey was not approved by the Department, and accused them of forum shopping. It then moved for a deficiency assessment, asserting that the total valuation of the two parcels was 387,410 pesos and that the 13,015 pesos in docket fees paid were insufficient.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court gravely abused its discretion in denying the motion for deficiency assessment on the ground that the subject matter of the case is incapable of pecuniary estimation.
- Whether or not the trial court gravely abused its discretion in holding that the relief of just compensation is merely incidental to the principal action, such that docket fees should not be based on the value of the realty.
Applicable Provisions
Section 7 of Rule 141 of the Rules of Court, as discussed in the decision, provides:
Section 7. Clerks of Court. The clerks of court shall collect the following fees: (a) For filing an action or a permissive counterclaim or money claim against an estate not based on judgment, or for filing a third-party, fourth-party, etc. complaint, or a complaint-in-intervention, if the action or claim is capable of pecuniary estimation, the amount shall be based on the fair market value of the real property in litigation, if any, or on the amount of the demand, whichever is higher; (b) For filing an action or proceeding the subject matter of which is not capable of pecuniary estimation, the amount shall be based on the value of the property in litigation or on the amount of the demand, whichever is higher.
This provision supplies the two-tiered schedule of filing fees, and the whole dispute turns on which paragraph governs the Cariño family's action.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petition lacks merit and that the trial court did not gravely abuse its discretion. Although the case involved real properties, a careful reading of the complaint shows that the family primarily challenged the validity of the taking of their alleged properties and assailed the various documents upon which that taking had been premised. The Court adopted the criterion laid down in Singson versus Isabella Sawmill, quoted in the decision:
In determining whether an action is one the subject matter of which is not capable of pecuniary estimation this Court has adopted the criterion of first ascertaining the nature of the principal action or remedy sought. However, where the basic issue is something other than the right to recover a sum of money, where the money claim is purely incidental to, or a consequence of, the principal relief sought, this Court has considered such actions as cases where the subject of litigation may not be estimated in terms of money, and are cognizable exclusively by courts of first instance, now Regional Trial Courts.
On the second issue, the Court held that the prayer for just compensation is only an alternative relief, not the main cause of action. Following De Ungria versus Court of Appeals, the Court characterized the case as one of joinder of causes of action that comprehends more than possession, because it includes the annulment of a survey plan and the reconveyance of the properties, which are incapable of pecuniary estimation. The Court stressed that the De Ungria ruling must be adhered to under the principle of stare decisis et non quieta movere, which it translated as the rule to adhere to precedents and not to unsettle things which are established, and it noted that sound policy dictates adherence to the more recent precedent, which supersedes prior decisions to the contrary. Since the trial court acted in complete accord with law and jurisprudence, there was no grave abuse of discretion, which the Court described as a capricious or whimsical exercise of judgment so patent and gross as to amount to an evasion of a positive duty or a virtual refusal to perform a duty enjoined by law.
Doctrine
First, to determine whether an action is incapable of pecuniary estimation, the court must first ascertain the nature of the principal action or remedy sought. If the basic issue is something other than the right to recover a sum of money, and the money claim is purely incidental to, or a consequence of, the principal relief, the action is incapable of pecuniary estimation and falls within the jurisdiction of the Regional Trial Court. Second, where a complaint joins a real action with causes of action to annul documents and to reconvey property, the joinder takes the case out of the simple category of recovery of possession, and filing fees are computed under paragraph (b) of Section 7 of Rule 141, not on the fair market value of the realty under paragraph (a). Third, a court that rules in accord with law and jurisprudence cannot be said to have acted with grave abuse of discretion, and certiorari will not lie. Fourth, under stare decisis, the Court adheres to its established precedents, and the more recent precedent supersedes prior decisions to the contrary.
Disposition
The petition for certiorari was dismissed for lack of merit, the assailed orders of the trial court were affirmed, and the trial court was directed to proceed with utmost dispatch in the trial of the case.
Remember This
Memorize the Singson criterion: look first at the nature of the principal action or remedy sought, and if the money claim is purely incidental to the principal relief, the action is incapable of pecuniary estimation. Examiners use this case to test docket fees and jurisdiction over actions involving real property with alternative prayers for just compensation, and to test the standard of grave abuse of discretion in a Rule 65 petition.