PEOPLE OF THE PHILIPPINES, ROCKLAND CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC., PETITIONER-APPELLANT, VS. MID-PASIG LAND DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, MAMERTO TARDIO, ALEX GAVANILLO, DAVID LOPEZ AND…
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
People versus Mid-Pasig Land Development Corporation
The Case
This is the case of the People of the Philippines, joined by Rockland Construction Company, Incorporated, against Mid-Pasig Land Development Corporation and several individual respondents. It reaches us not on the merits of the original controversy but on a much narrower question: what happens when a party, after losing, files a motion for reconsideration that merely repeats the very arguments already raised and already resolved. The Supreme Court's brief resolution is a standing reminder that a motion for reconsideration is not a second chance to re-argue a decided case, and that recycling old arguments is a ground for denial, not for relief.
Procedural History
The case began in the trial court and then went up on appeal. The Supreme Court rendered a Decision on June 30, 2014, which disposed of the appeal. The petitioner-appellant, dissatisfied, filed a Motion for Reconsideration of that Decision. The appellees responded by filing a Comment on the motion. The matter then came before the Supreme Court for resolution of the motion for reconsideration, and it is that motion which the Court rules upon here.
Facts
The petitioner-appellant lost before the Supreme Court when the Court issued its Decision on June 30, 2014. Seeking to overturn that result, the petitioner-appellant filed a Motion for Reconsideration.
The appellees filed a Comment opposing the motion. When the Court examined the motion, it found that the arguments raised were not new at all. They were a mere rehash of the arguments the petitioner-appellant had already presented earlier in the proceedings.
Those same arguments had already been passed upon and resolved by the Court in the Decision sought to be reconsidered. There was, in short, nothing fresh for the Court to rule upon.
Issues
- Whether or not a motion for reconsideration that merely rehashes arguments already presented and already resolved by the Court should be granted.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote or construe any statutory or constitutional provision. It rests entirely on the procedural rule governing motions for reconsideration, namely that such a motion must raise grounds not already passed upon. Because the decision text supplies no verbatim provision, none is quoted here.
Ruling
The Court denied the motion for reconsideration for lack of merit. Its reason was straightforward: the arguments raised in the motion were a mere rehash of those already presented and already passed upon and resolved in the Decision sought to be reconsidered. A motion that offers nothing new gives the Court no basis to disturb its prior ruling. The Court stated its conclusion in these words:
We have noticed that the arguments raised in the present motion are mere rehash of those arguments already presented and which have been passed upon and resolved in the Decision sought to be reconsidered.
Accordingly, the Court resolved the motion in this manner:
Wherefore, the present Motion for Reconsideration is denied for lack of merit.
Doctrine
A motion for reconsideration must raise a ground not already passed upon by the Court. Where the movant merely repeats arguments already presented and already resolved in the decision sought to be reconsidered, the motion is a mere rehash and must be denied for lack of merit. The Court will not re-litigate what it has already decided simply because a losing party asks again.
Disposition
The petitioner-appellant lost: the Supreme Court denied the Motion for Reconsideration for lack of merit, leaving its June 30, 2014 Decision undisturbed.
Remember This
The line to memorize is that a motion for reconsideration raising a mere rehash of arguments already passed upon and resolved is denied for lack of merit. Examiners use this case on the procedural point of what a valid motion for reconsideration must contain, and on the consequence of merely repeating arguments already rejected.