ARNOLD N. ALEJANDRO, PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT, VS. SPOUSES FELIX OLIVARES AND BUENAFE OLIVARES, DEFENDANTS-APPELLEES.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Alejandro versus Olivares
The Case
This is Alejandro versus Olivares, a case about whether a dismissed ejectment suit bars a later, fuller action to recover possession of land. Arnold Alejandro sued Spouses Felix and Buenafe Olivares to recover a commercial lot in Mangaldan, Pangasinan, claiming he owned it by donation from his parents and that the spouses occupied it only by his tolerance. The spouses answered that they had bought the land from his parents under a contract to sell and had fully paid. The case matters because the trial court threw the complaint out on a technical ground, forum shopping, and the Supreme Court had to remind everyone of a basic remedial distinction: a judgment in ejectment settles only possession, not ownership, and so cannot bar a plenary suit over the same land.
Procedural History
Alejandro filed his complaint for recovery of possession in 2008 before the Regional Trial Court. Before that, he had filed an ejectment case against the same spouses before the Municipal Trial Court of Mangaldan, Pangasinan, which dismissed it; on appeal, the Regional Trial Court affirmed the dismissal. In the 2008 case, the parties stipulated at pre-trial to the identity of the lot, to the fact that it was originally owned by Alejandro's parents, and to the prior ejectment case and its affirmance. The trial court then summarily dismissed the complaint with prejudice, finding that Alejandro had engaged in forum shopping. Alejandro appealed. The Court of Appeals later affirmed the trial court's decision. The matter then reached the Supreme Court, which granted the appeal and reversed.
Facts
Alejandro claimed exclusive ownership of a commercial lot in Mangaldan, Pangasinan, which he said he acquired by a deed of donation from his parents. He alleged that Spouses Olivares occupied the property by his sheer tolerance, and that they resisted his formal demand to relinquish possession, which forced him to sue for recovery of possession in 2008.
The spouses, for their part, asserted ownership under a contract to sell from Alejandro's parents. They stressed that Buenafe Olivares is a sibling of Alejandro's father, and that their installment payments culminated in full payment for the property in 2005. On that basis they argued that the complaint stated no cause of action.
At the pre-trial conference the parties conceded several matters: the identity of the lot, which is covered by a tax declaration obtained after the sale of the land by Alejandro's parents; that the land was originally owned by Alejandro's parents; and that an ejectment case Alejandro had filed before the Municipal Trial Court of Mangaldan was dismissed and that dismissal was affirmed on appeal by the Regional Trial Court. Discovery began with the partial direct examination of Alejandro's witness, and the case was referred to mediation, which produced no settlement. The trial court then issued the decision summarily dismissing the case.
Issues
- Whether or not the plaintiff violated the rule on forum shopping by filing the action for recovery of possession after his ejectment case had been dismissed and that dismissal affirmed.
- Whether or not the trial court properly dismissed the complaint with prejudice on the ground of forum shopping.
- Whether or not the judgment in the ejectment case operates as res judicata, or a bar, against the later action to recover possession.
Applicable Provisions
Section 18 of Rule 70 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure provides:
Such judgment shall not bar an action between the same parties respecting title to the land or building.
This is the decisive text: it expressly preserves a separate suit over title even after an ejectment judgment, which defeats the trial court's forum shopping theory.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that there was no forum shopping. Forum shopping requires identity of parties, identity of the rights asserted and relief prayed for founded on the same facts, and an identity such that a judgment in one action would amount to res judicata in the other. The Court stressed that the mere filing of several cases arising from the same incident does not necessarily constitute forum shopping; the test is whether the actions involve the same transactions, the same essential facts and circumstances, and identical causes of action, subject matter, and issues.
On the second issue, the Court held that the summary dismissal was improper. It relied on the express language of Section 18 of Rule 70:
Such judgment shall not bar an action between the same parties respecting title to the land or building.
Because the Rules themselves acknowledge the dichotomy between an action for desahucio, that is, ejectment, and a suit involving title or ownership, the prior ejectment case could not be a bar.
On the third issue, the Court held that the ejectment judgment was not res judicata against the recovery of possession. There was no identity of causes of action. An ejectment case involves a different cause of action from an accion publiciana, the plenary action to recover the right of possession, or an accion reinvindicatoria, the action to recover ownership which includes possession. A judgment in forcible entry or detainer disposes of no other issue than possession and establishes only who has the right of possession; it does not bar an action to determine who has the right or title of ownership. The Court also noted that the trial court itself found the 2008 case to be more of an accion reinvindicatoria, since Alejandro alleged registered ownership and complained of the spouses' construction and continuous occupation. Having resolved the threshold procedural question, the Court declined to rule prematurely on the other factual matters raised on appeal, leaving them to unfold at trial.
Doctrine
- Forum shopping requires identity of parties, identity of rights asserted and relief prayed for founded on the same facts, and an identity such that any judgment in one action would amount to res judicata in the other.
- The mere filing of several cases based on the same incident is not forum shopping; the actions must raise identical causes of action, subject matter, and issues.
- Under Section 18 of Rule 70, a judgment in ejectment shall not bar an action between the same parties respecting title to the land or building.
- An ejectment suit is limited to possession de facto; it is distinct from the accion publiciana, which recovers the right of possession, and the accion reinvindicatoria, which recovers ownership including possession.
- A judgment in forcible entry or detainer is not res judicata against a later action over ownership or the right of possession, because there is no identity of causes of action.
Disposition
The appeal was granted insofar as it sought reversal of the trial court's decision, and the trial court was directed to proceed with the hearing of the parties' evidence.
Remember This
Memorize this line: an ejectment judgment settles only possession and never bars a suit respecting title. Examiners use this case to test forum shopping and res judicata against the three actions for recovery of possession: ejectment, accion publiciana, and accion reinvindicatoria.