IN RE: PETITION FOR CORRECTION OF ENTRY IN THE CERTIFICATE OF LIVE BIRTH OF RENELLE JENZEN S. DEL ROSARIO,
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
In re: Petition for Correction of Entry in the Certificate of Live Birth of Renelle Jenzen S. Del Rosario
The Case
This is the Republic of the Philippines, through the Office of the Solicitor General, against Renelle Jenzen S. Del Rosario — a petition for correction of entry in the civil registry, specifically to change the gender appearing in her certificate of live birth from female to male. The Republic appeals the grant of that petition. The case matters for two reasons a reviewee must hold onto: it fixes the line between a substantial correction governed by Rule 108 of the Rules of Court and a mere clerical or typographical error correctable administratively, and it teaches that admissibility of evidence is not the same as its probative value — a hearsay medical certificate, even if unobjected to, proves nothing.
Procedural History
Renelle Jenzen filed her petition for correction of entry before the Regional Trial Court, Branch 224, Quezon City. The trial court found the petition sufficient in form and substance, ordered notice and publication, and after an ex parte presentation of evidence rendered its Decision on July 9, 2012, granting the correction and ordering the Civil Registrar of Quezon City to change the gender in the certificate of live birth from female to male. The Office of the Solicitor General moved for reconsideration, which the trial court denied in its Order of October 31, 2012. The Republic then appealed to the Supreme Court, assigning as errors the grant of the petition without the testimony of the examining doctor and the failure to avail of the administrative remedy. The Supreme Court resolved the appeal on the merits, and the appeal was granted.
Facts
Renelle Jenzen alleged that she was born male on July 27, 1988 in Quezon City, but that her certificate of live birth registered her as female. On September 15, 2011, she sought correction of her gender before the Regional Trial Court of Quezon City. The trial court ordered the posting of notice and publication in a newspaper of general circulation in Metro Manila for three consecutive weeks, and Renelle Jenzen complied. The Office of the Solicitor General entered its appearance and authorized the City Prosecutor of Quezon City to appear on its behalf.
To prove her claim, Renelle Jenzen testified during the ex parte presentation of evidence before the Branch Clerk of Court. She then submitted a formal offer of evidence consisting of her secondary student's permanent record at St. Jude College, a medical certificate issued by Dr. Yvonne C. Bernales-Mariano stating that the patient has been examined and found to be anatomically and phenotypically male in gender, and a driver's license — although a copy of the driver's license did not form part of the records. The doctor who issued the medical certificate was never presented in court to identify it or confirm its contents.
The trial court granted the petition, holding that Renelle Jenzen had established her claim by preponderance of evidence and that the relief was sanctioned under Section 2, Rule 108 of the Rules of Court. The Republic moved for reconsideration, which was denied, and the Republic appealed.
Issues
- Whether or not the trial court erred in granting the petition for correction of entry in the absence of the testimony of the doctor who examined the petitioner.
- Whether or not the trial court erred in granting the petition despite the availability of an administrative remedy under the law on correction of clerical or typographical errors.
Applicable Provisions
Section 2, Rule 108 of the Rules of Court, cited by the trial court as the basis for the correction, provides:
Section 2. Entries subject to cancellation or correction. — Upon good and valid grounds, the following entries in the civil register may be cancelled or corrected: (a) births; (b) marriages; (c) deaths; (d) legal separations; (e) judgments of annulment of marriage; (f) judgments declaring marriages void from the beginning; (g) legitimations; (h) acknowledgments of natural children; (i) naturalization; (j) election, loss or recovery of citizenship; (k) civil interdiction; (l) judicial determination of filiation; (m) voluntary emancipation of a minor; and (n) changes of name.
This is the judicial route invoked by Renelle Jenzen, and the Court holds that a change of sex is a substantial correction that falls under this Rule, not a clerical error.
Republic Act Number 9048, as amended by Republic Act Number 10172, is the administrative remedy pressed by the Republic. The Court describes it as the law authorizing the city or municipal civil registrar or the consul general to correct a clerical or typographical error in an entry and change of first name or nickname in the civil register without need of a judicial order, and notes that Republic Act Number 10172 authorized the registrars to correct clerical or typographical errors in the day and month in the date of birth or sex of a person appearing in the civil register without need of a judicial order. The Court holds that this law does not apply to the pending petition because it contains nothing providing for retroactive application or transferring pending petitions to the civil registrar.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court ruled that the trial court erred. The medical certificate issued by Dr. Bernales-Mariano is hearsay because the doctor was never presented in court to identify the report or confirm its contents. A medical certificate involves the opinion of one who must first be established as an expert witness, and it cannot be given weight unless the doctor is presented to show qualifications. The Republic's failure to timely object amounted only to a waiver of the right to object to admissibility, and the Court drew the critical distinction:
Admissibility refers to the question of whether certain pieces of evidence are to be considered at all, while probative value refers to the question of whether the admitted evidence proves an issue.
The Court held that a hearsay evidence, whether objected to or not, has no probative value. Neither could the uncorroborated testimony of Renelle Jenzen, her high school record, and her driver's license — which was not submitted and formed no part of the records — establish that she was born male and that the entry was a typographical error. He who alleges must prove.
On the second issue, the Court ruled that Rule 108 of the Rules of Court governs. Jurisdiction is determined by the law in force at the time the action was filed, and jurisdiction already acquired is not affected by new legislation placing jurisdiction over such proceedings in another tribunal, unless the statute expressly provides or is construed to operate on pending actions. When Renelle Jenzen filed her petition on September 12, 2011, Republic Act Number 9048 had not yet been amended, and under the Court's ruling in Republic versus Silverio, correction of entry involving change of sex remains a substantial change governed by Rule 108, not a mere clerical or typographical error. The trial court therefore validly acquired jurisdiction, and Republic Act Number 10172, approved on August 15, 2012, did not divest it.
Doctrine
- A change of sex in the civil registry is a substantial correction governed by Rule 108 of the Rules of Court, not a clerical or typographical error correctable administratively.
- Jurisdiction is determined by the law in force at the time the action was filed; new legislation transferring jurisdiction does not affect a court that has already acquired jurisdiction, absent an express or implied intent to reach pending actions.
- Admissibility is not probative value. A hearsay document, even if admitted without objection, has no probative value; a medical certificate is worthless unless its author is presented to establish expertise and identify it.
- He who alleges must prove. A bare allegation of gender, unsupported by competent evidence, cannot sustain a petition for correction of entry.
Disposition
The appeal was granted; the trial court's Decision and Order were reversed and set aside, and the petition for correction of entry filed by Renelle Jenzen S. Del Rosario was dismissed for lack of evidence.
Remember This
Memorize the line that admissibility is not probative value — hearsay, objected to or not, proves nothing. Examiners use this case to test the Rule 108 versus administrative correction boundary and the weight of an unverified medical certificate.