CORDOVA HOME VILLAGE/EDELIZA HANZEN/ERIK HANZEN, PETITIONERS, VS. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS COMMISSION, SEVENTH DIVISION, GLEEN TUBILLA, VIRGINIA ZAMORA, BENIGNO GAVIOLA, CERILO …
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Cordova Home Village versus National Labor Relations Commission
The Case
This is a labor case that reached the Supreme Court as a petition by Cordova Home Village, together with Edeliza Hanzen and Erik Hanzen, against the National Labor Relations Commission, Seventh Division, and a group of private respondents led by Gleen Tubilla, Virginia Zamora, and Benigno Gaviola, among others. The petitioners sought relief from the labor tribunals' rulings, and the private respondents opposed them. The case matters less for any grand labor-law doctrine than for a procedural lesson every reviewee must carry: when the parties settle and satisfy the judgment while the case is pending, the controversy becomes moot and academic, and the Court will dismiss it. It is a study in the life and death of a case through settlement.
Procedural History
The dispute began before the labor arbiter, who rendered a decision ordering the respondents to pay the complainants a sum of money. The case then went up to the National Labor Relations Commission, where it was assigned to the Seventh Division. From the Commission, the petitioners brought the matter to the Court of Appeals by way of a petition. While the petition was pending before the Court of Appeals, the parties entered into a settlement for the satisfaction of the judgment before the Acting Executive Labor Arbiter of the Regional Arbitration Branch of the National Labor Relations Commission. On the strength of that settlement, the parties filed a Joint Motion to Dismiss before the Court of Appeals. The Court of Appeals, finding that a Satisfaction of Judgment had already been rendered, declared the petition moot and academic and dismissed it with prejudice. The matter then reached the Supreme Court.
Facts
The complainants, who are the private respondents here, obtained a decision in their favor ordering the respondents, the petitioners here, to pay them the amount of three hundred twenty-eight thousand three hundred fifty-three pesos and eleven centavos. Rather than pursue the case to its end, the parties chose to settle.
The complainants accepted from the respondents the sum of two hundred forty-six thousand two hundred sixty-four pesos and eighty-three centavos as full satisfaction of the decision. Both sides, through their respective counsel, executed a Satisfaction of Judgment and prayed that it be duly entered in the docket. The document was executed in Cebu City on June 19, 2014.
On June 24, 2014, the parties filed a Joint Motion to Dismiss before the Court of Appeals, attaching the Satisfaction of Judgment signed by both counsels. The Court of Appeals received the motion and forwarded it to the Division Clerk of Court. Confronted with a judgment already satisfied, the Court of Appeals granted the motion and dismissed the case.
Issues
- Whether or not the petition was rendered moot and academic by the parties' execution of a Satisfaction of Judgment before the labor arbiter.
- Whether or not the Joint Motion to Dismiss filed by both parties should be granted.
Applicable Provisions
The decision does not quote a specific statutory provision; it rests on the procedural principle of mootness and on the parties' Satisfaction of Judgment, which recites the terms of their settlement. The Satisfaction of Judgment states the amount awarded and the amount accepted, as follows:
WHEREAS, a Decision was rendered in the above-entitled case ordering the respondent to pay the complainant the amount of PESOS: THREE HUNDRED TWENTY-EIGHT THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED FIFTY-THREE & 11/100 (P328,353.11);
This recital fixes the judgment debt that the settlement was meant to satisfy.
WHEREAS, complainants have accepted the sum of PESOS: TWO HUNDRED FORTY-SIX THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED SIXTY-FOUR & 83/100 (P246, 264.83) from the respondents as full satisfaction of the said decision;
This recital shows that the judgment was fully satisfied, which is the fact that rendered the petition moot.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the petition had indeed been rendered moot and academic. Its reasoning turned on the existence of the Satisfaction of Judgment already rendered before the Acting Executive Labor Arbiter. The Court stated:
Considering that there is already a Satisfaction of Judgment rendered before Acting Executive Labor Arbiter, Regional Arbitrtion, Branch No. VII of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC), the instant petition is deemed moot and academic.
On the second issue, the Court granted the Joint Motion to Dismiss, as prayed for by both parties, and dismissed the case with prejudice. Because the judgment had been satisfied, there remained no live controversy for the Court to resolve.
Doctrine
A case becomes moot and academic when the parties have settled and fully satisfied the judgment, leaving no actual controversy for the court to resolve. When both parties jointly move to dismiss on the ground of a Satisfaction of Judgment, the court will grant the motion and dismiss the case with prejudice. A dismissal with prejudice means the case is closed for good and cannot be relitigated. The Satisfaction of Judgment, reciting the amount awarded and the amount accepted in full satisfaction, is the operative fact that extinguishes the controversy.
Disposition
The Court granted the Joint Motion to Dismiss and dismissed the case with prejudice, the petition having been rendered moot and academic by the Satisfaction of Judgment.
Remember This
The single line to memorize: a judgment fully satisfied by settlement renders the pending petition moot and academic, and the case is dismissed with prejudice. Examiners use this case to test mootness and the effect of a Satisfaction of Judgment in labor proceedings.