CYNTHIA A. FLORENDO, COMPLAINANT, VS. EXEQUIEL ENRILE, RESPONDENT.
Listen, read along, or open presentation mode.
Florendo versus Enrile
The Case
This is an administrative case filed by Cynthia A. Florendo against Exequiel Enrile, a deputy sheriff of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Cabanatuan City. The complainant charged the respondent with failing to enforce a writ of demolition even after he had collected and received 5,200 pesos from her, purportedly as sheriff's fees. The case matters because it fixes the standard of conduct for sheriffs and court personnel, and because it shows how the Supreme Court treats grave misconduct, gross dishonesty, and neglect of duty in the judiciary — the penalty is dismissal, not a fine, and the complainant's own willingness to withdraw the case cannot soften that result.
Procedural History
The complainant filed a sworn letter-complaint with the Office of the Court Administrator on 17 March 1992. The Supreme Court required the respondent to comment, and he filed a comment denominated as an answer dated 16 June 1992. The Court then referred the case to the Executive Judge of the Regional Trial Court in Cabanatuan City for investigation, report, and recommendation. Executive Judge Johnson L. Ballutay submitted his Report and Recommendation dated 4 March 1994, transmitted to the Court only on 6 June 1994, recommending suspension without pay for one year, return of the 5,200 pesos, and an additional suspension without pay for six months. By resolution of 8 August 1994, the Court referred that report to the Office of the Court Administrator for evaluation, report, and recommendation. The Office of the Court Administrator, in its Memorandum of 23 September 1994, found considerable neglect of duty and recommended a fine equivalent to one month's salary and return of the 5,200 pesos. The Court disagreed with both recommendations and decided the case itself as an administrative matter.
Facts
The complainant was the plaintiff in several ejectment cases before Branch 2 of the Municipal Trial Court in Cities of Cabanatuan City. In a joint decision rendered on 22 June 1987, the defendants were ordered to vacate the premises and surrender possession to her. The defendants appealed to the Regional Trial Court, which affirmed the decision in toto on 18 August 1989. On 19 January 1990, the Municipal Trial Court issued a writ of execution, and the writ was assigned to the respondent for implementation. Because the defendants refused to vacate, the complainant asked for a writ of demolition, which the court granted by order of 21 March 1990. On 27 June 1990, the court denied the defendants' motion for extension of time to execute the writ of demolition.
For the service and implementation of the writ of demolition, the respondent asked for and received from the complainant and her lawyer a total of 5,200 pesos, purportedly as sheriff's fee. He issued no official receipt. His acknowledgment of a partial payment of 2,700 pesos appears on the stationery of the complainant's lawyer, Atty. Edgardo G. Villarin; his acknowledgment of another payment of 500 pesos is handwritten on the stationery of the Office of the City Legal Officer, who is the same Atty. Villarin; and the remaining 2,000 pesos was paid by check drawn by the complainant's counsel. Despite receiving the money, the respondent did not execute the writ of demolition. The complainant's lawyer wrote to him on 8 November 1990 demanding implementation of the writ or return of the sum within ten days, failing which the matter would be brought to the Supreme Court. Nothing was done, and the complaint followed.
In his defense, the respondent did not deny collecting the 5,200 pesos. He claimed he served the writ of demolition on the defendants on 25 July 1990, that they asked for a thirty-day extension, and that when he returned on 4 September 1990 he was threatened with death if he enforced the writ. He prepared returns of service dated 25 July 1990 and 4 September 1990, but these were filed with the Municipal Trial Court only on 29 May 1991 and 6 June 1991. The Clerk of Court, Arsenio S. Vicencio, reported to the presiding judge that the threat was real and requested that a new deputy sheriff be assigned, and the judge asked that deputy sheriff Teodoro Pineda be assigned to implement the writ.
Issues
- Whether or not the respondent is guilty of grave misconduct and gross dishonesty for collecting 5,200 pesos as sheriff's fees without issuing an official receipt and without court approval.
- Whether or not the respondent is guilty of serious dereliction or neglect of duty, gross inefficiency or incompetence, and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service for failing to implement the writ of demolition and for belatedly filing his returns of service.
- Whether or not the complainant's conformity to the dismissal of the complaint may be considered a mitigating circumstance.
- Whether or not the penalty recommended by the investigating judge and the Office of the Court Administrator is proper.
Applicable Provisions
Section 11 of Rule 39 of the Rules of Court provides:
A writ of execution should be returned at any time not less than ten days nor more than sixty days after its receipt by the sheriff who must set forth in writing on its back the whole of his proceedings by virtue thereof and file it with the clerk or judge to be preserved with the other papers in the case.
This fixes the period within which the sheriff must return the writ, and the respondent's returns were filed months beyond it.
The Manual for Clerks of Court provides:
When a writ is placed in the hands of the sheriff, it is his duty in the absence of instructions, to proceed with reasonable celerity and promptness to execute it in accordance with its mandate. He has no discretion whether to execute it or not.
This establishes that execution is a ministerial duty, which the respondent failed to perform.
The same Manual also provides:
All sheriffs and deputy sheriffs shall submit a report to the Judge concerned on the action taken on all writs and processes assigned to them within ten days from receipt of said process or writ. Said report shall form part of the records of the case.
This required the respondent to report promptly, which he did not do.
Ruling
On the first issue, the Court held that the respondent was liable for grave misconduct and gross dishonesty. He never denied receiving the 5,200 pesos and issued no official receipt. At the time the writ of demolition was placed in his hands, the basic amount payable was only 8 pesos under paragraph (g), Section 7, Rule 141 of the Rules of Court, later increased to 100 pesos. Other sheriff's expenses must be estimated by the sheriff, approved by the court, deposited with the clerk of court and ex-officio sheriff, disbursed to the deputy sheriff, and liquidated with the return, with any unspent amount refunded. The respondent made no report and issued no receipt, so, as the Court put it, he asked for the amount not as lawful fees alone but as a consideration for the performance of his duty. Any portion in excess of the lawful fees is an unlawful exaction.
On the second issue, the Court held that the respondent was guilty of serious dereliction or neglect of duty, gross inefficiency or incompetence, and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service. His returns dated 25 July 1990 and 4 September 1990 were filed only on 29 May 1991 and 6 June 1991. Either he dated them correctly, in which case there was deliberate and unreasonable delay in filing, or he antedated them. The Court stressed that the duty to execute the writ is ministerial, not directory, and defined a purely ministerial act as one performed in a given state of facts, in a prescribed manner, in obedience to the mandate of legal authority, without regard to the officer's own judgment on the propriety of the act. His claim of a death threat was unacceptable: he should have reported it and requested assistance, or filed a criminal complaint, instead of filing his returns months later.
On the third issue, the Court held that the complainant's conformity to the dismissal could not mitigate liability. A complaint for misconduct against a public officer cannot be withdrawn at the whim of the complainant, who is in a real sense only a witness, because the need to maintain public faith in the government demands that such proceedings not depend on the complainant's caprice.
On the fourth issue, the Court held that both recommended penalties were grossly inadequate, and that the additional six-month suspension recommended by the investigating judge was improper because the delay in the investigation was partly his own fault. The Court imposed dismissal from the service with forfeiture of all benefits and with prejudice to re-employment in any branch of the government, including government-owned or controlled corporations.
Doctrine
A sheriff's duty to execute a writ is ministerial, not directory; he has no discretion whether to execute it or not, and must act with reasonable celerity and promptness. A sheriff who collects fees beyond those lawfully allowed, without court approval and without official receipt, is guilty of grave misconduct and gross dishonesty, and the excess is an unlawful exaction. A complaint for misconduct against a public officer cannot be withdrawn at any time by the complainant, whose conformity to dismissal is not a mitigating circumstance. The conduct of everyone in the judiciary, from the presiding judge to the lowest clerk, must be circumscribed with the heavy burden of responsibility and must be above suspicion.
Disposition
The Court found the respondent guilty of grave misconduct, gross dishonesty, serious dereliction or neglect of duty, gross incompetence or inefficiency, and conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service, and ordered him dismissed from the service with forfeiture of all benefits and with prejudice to re-employment in any branch of the government, including government-owned or controlled corporations, the decision being immediately executory.
Remember This
The line worth memorizing is that the sheriff's duty to execute a writ is ministerial, not directory, and that collecting unauthorized fees is grave misconduct and gross dishonesty. Examiners use this case to test the standard of conduct of court personnel and the rule that a complainant's withdrawal or conformity does not bar or mitigate an administrative case against a public officer.