Facts:
The consolidated case primarily challenges the eligibility of Ronald Allan Kelly Poe (a.k.a. Fernando Poe, Jr. or FPJ) to run for the presidency of the Republic of the Philippines in the May 2004 elections, emphasizing a crucial constitutional query: Is FPJ a natural-born Filipino citizen?
On 31 December 2003, FPJ filed his certificate of candidacy, claiming natural-born Philippine citizenship. Victorino X. Fornier initiated a petition (SPA No. 04-003) before the COMELEC, arguing FPJ’s ineligibility on grounds that his parents were foreigners, rendering him non-natural-born. Fornier posited that FPJ’s father was Spanish and his mother, American; hence, FPJ, an alleged illegitimate child, could not inherit Filipino citizenship from a purportedly Filipino father.
The COMELEC’s Fact-Finding Division heard the case on 19 January 2004. Fornier presented various documents to challenge FPJ’s eligibility, while FPJ countered with evidence supporting his Filipino lineage. The COMELEC dismissed the petition for lack of merit on 23 January 2004. Fornier’s subsequent motion for reconsideration was denied by the COMELEC en banc on 06 February 2004, prompting the escalation to the Supreme Court.
Issues:
1. Jurisdiction to review the COMELEC’s decision on FPJ’s disqualification case.
2. Determination of FPJ’s eligibility as a natural-born Filipino citizen in the context of his paternal ancestry and circumstances of birth.
3. Interpretation of laws and the constitution regarding citizenship, with emphasis on the legitimacy of birth affecting citizenship transmission.
Court’s Decision:
The Supreme Court held that it had jurisdiction over the case, citing its authority to review decisions of the COMELEC. While it recognized G.R. No. 161824 (Fornier vs. COMELEC and Poe) based on Rule 64 in relation to Rule 65 of the Revised Rules of Civil Procedure due to its direct challenge on COMELEC’s ruling on FPJ’s disqualification case, it dismissed G.R. No. 161434 and G.R. No. 161634 for lack of jurisdiction and prematurity, underlining that the Supreme Court’s jurisdiction as an electoral tribunal pertains to a post-election scenario.
Resolving FPJ’s citizenship, the Court found that FPJ is a natural-born Filipino, recognizing entitlement to Philippine citizenship from his paternal lineage traced to a Filipino father, Lorenzo Pou, born around 1870, who likely became a Filipino citizen by virtue of the Treaty of Paris and the Philippine Bill of 1902. The alleged illegitimacy of FPJ did not negate his claim to natural-born citizenship since the 1935 Constitution did not distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate children concerning the transmission of citizenship.
Doctrine:
The Supreme Court reiterated the principle that a person’s eligibility for public office, specifically the presidency, hinges on the constitutional requirement of being a natural-born citizen of the Philippines. It emphasized that the determination of citizenship for electoral qualification should not be strictly bound by the provisions of civil law on legitimacy, as political law governs such determinations.
Class Notes:
– Citizenship may be acquired by jus sanguinis (right of blood), which emphasizes descent or parentage, rather than jus soli (right of soil).
– The Philippine legal system recognizes natural-born citizens as those who are citizens from birth without having to perform any act to acquire or perfect their Philippine citizenship.
– The determination of natural-born citizenship for eligibility to office does not distinguish between legitimate and illegitimate children.
Historical Background:
This case reflects the Philippines’ nuanced legal considerations on citizenship, eligibility to the presidency, and the intersection of family and constitutional law. It underscores the enduring impact of the nation’s colonial history and the evolution of laws from the Spanish Colonial Code to contemporary times, upon which citizenship issues are adjudicated. This decision also symbolizes the Philippine Supreme Court’s pivotal role in clarifying and upholding constitutional mandates relating to the highest elected positions in the country.
Leave a Reply